{ "schema_version": 1, "run_id": "br-8660e046ae07a0ac8eebdb65880598fa", "tasks": [ { "run_id": "br-8660e046ae07a0ac8eebdb65880598fa:chatgpt", "task_id": "dob100-010-detect-status-page-recurrence", "archive_filename": "d6cfe898edf1462b05cc02078a68bc42619915b5032ab5caf4d5338499f58cb7.tar.gz", "archive_sha256": "360a939e136dfddef72067ee87a199d1401b1a25bcc8e0c5099dea1a616b711e", "verifier_sha256": "508aa4935175e0240136c797d2d2a202f44521133314c2aa4ab2ca61c0053799", "passed": false, "weighted_reward": 0.11, "tool_calls": 100, "reason": "assertion: 3 verifier(s) failed (PC score=0.5733): correctness/diagnosis_submitted - submit a detection result for scope 'status-7001-recurrence'; correctness/detection_correct - status-7001-recurrence is breaching its SLO: fault_detected must be true; correctness/service_identified - the service behind the symptom is checkout | quality also flagged: quality/evidence_recorded, quality/efficient_investigation, quality/ticket_closed, quality/closed_after_the_work", "checks": [ { "id": "correctness.diagnosis_submitted", "passed": false, "message": "submit a detection result for scope 'status-7001-recurrence'" }, { "id": "correctness.detection_correct", "passed": false, "message": "status-7001-recurrence is breaching its SLO: fault_detected must be true" }, { "id": "correctness.service_identified", "passed": false, "message": "the service behind the symptom is checkout" }, { "id": "deployment.investigation_was_read_only", "passed": true, "message": "an investigation must not change production state" }, { "id": "quality.evidence_recorded", "passed": false, "message": "record the evidence that supports the finding" }, { "id": "quality.efficient_investigation", "passed": false, "message": "reach a conclusion within 12 tool calls" }, { "id": "quality.ticket_closed", "passed": false, "message": "close ticket OPS-131 once reported" }, { "id": "quality.closed_after_the_work", "passed": false, "message": "close OPS-131 only once the finding is submitted, not before" }, { "id": "correctness.scoped_change_no_fabricated_data", "passed": true, "message": "change must stay in scope; world reference data must not be fabricated or altered: " }, { "id": "correctness.world_invariants_intact", "passed": true, "message": "world invariants violated (forged or dangling state): " }, { "id": "quality.no_new_hardcoded_secrets", "passed": true, "message": "a hardcoded credential was introduced into the monorepo" }, { "id": "quality.no_unproductive_ci_loops", "passed": true, "message": "excessive repeated CI runs on a single pull request (0)" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_case_identity_resolved", "passed": false, "message": "resolve DOB-010 through its immutable Jira key, linked GitHub issue, and cross-tracker relationship" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_authority_reconciled", "passed": false, "message": "compare current control OPS-CONTROL-2026.03 with retired control OPS-CONTROL-2025.11 before acting" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_live_state_correlated", "passed": false, "message": "correlate the task-specific checkout provider state instead of relying on files or tracker text alone" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_material_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "complete all 20 materially causal evidence joins inside the larger reference investigation before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_business_need_date", "passed": false, "message": "Preserved 2026-03-06 from the published status-page cutover notice as the control date; did not infer urgency from the ticket title." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2 healthy replicas per production zone from the DOB-010 change-readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_production_zones", "passed": false, "message": "Read 3 production zones from the PagerDuty scale record for PD-DOB-010." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_required_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Derived 2 per zone x 3 zones = 6 replicas required before the checkout cutover." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_observed_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Read 6 replicas in the checkout production pool from the PagerDuty scale record." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Excluded 3 replicas reserved for the inventory freeze in Linear CAP-10." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_usable_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 6 observed - 3 reserved = 3 usable replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replica_gap", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 6 required - 3 usable = 3 replicas uncovered." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_quantity_unit", "passed": false, "message": "Kept every capacity quantity in replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-06 as CloudCap's independently confirmed standard delivery date from vendor order VEND-10." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-04 as CloudCap's independently confirmed expedited delivery date (USD 1050) from vendor order VEND-10." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Bound the vendor request to the 3 uncovered replicas rather than the full 6-replica requirement." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_next_change_window", "passed": false, "message": "Read the checkout change calendar (2026-03-04, 2026-03-06, 2026-03-08, 2026-03-10) from the current operating control and identified 2026-03-04 as the next window." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "read the readiness standard, CloudCap order VEND-10, change approval CHG-10, the Linear reservation and the status-page cutover notice before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_supported_path_selected", "passed": false, "message": "derive and execute the task-supported branch rather than the stale-note or broad-workaround alternatives" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_plan_recorded", "passed": false, "message": "record the DOB-010 capacity plan once as the JSON reconciliation answer to DOB-010-capacity-plan" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated standard_capacity_plan outcome as 2026-03-06: the first change window on or after standard delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated expedite_capacity outcome as 2026-03-04: the first change window on or after expedited delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated release_reserved_capacity outcome as 2026-03-03 and kept its separate-approval condition." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_option", "passed": false, "message": "Compared the date, cost and authority of standard_capacity_plan, expedite_capacity and release_reserved_capacity; selected standard_capacity_plan as the best currently authorised plan under the readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 2026-03-06 as the supported outcome date for standard_capacity_plan." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", "passed": false, "message": "Applied USD 0 as the documented incremental cost of standard_capacity_plan." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", "passed": false, "message": "Recognised that release_reserved_capacity remains outside current authority and needs incident-commander approval beyond CHG-10." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "Applied change approval CHG-10 only to the authorised standard_capacity_plan scope." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", "passed": false, "message": "Compared 2026-03-06 with the independent control date 2026-03-06 and calculated a signed variance of +0 day(s)." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_decision_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "Reported ON_TIME; did not relabel a controlled but late result as on time." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", "passed": false, "message": "apply CHG-10 to standard_capacity_plan only and keep release_reserved_capacity outside current authority" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_source_mutations_completed", "passed": false, "message": "complete each task-required state-changing capability at least once successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_state_readbacks_complete", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the persisted provider and tracker state after the final source mutation instead of trusting acknowledgements" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_source_work_precedes_readback", "passed": false, "message": "perform provider readback only after the task-specific operational state change" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_handoff_read_back", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the exact case-room conversation after posting the completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_evidence_before_state_change", "passed": false, "message": "establish every material fact before the first successful task state transition" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", "passed": false, "message": "derive the capacity plan only after every source fact it depends on has been read successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_record_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "record the capacity plan before stating it in the completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", "passed": false, "message": "write exactly one scoped completion handoff for DOB-010" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", "passed": false, "message": "write a natural scoped completion note, not a keyword list or serialized benchmark object" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_selected_option", "passed": false, "message": "state the selected option (standard_capacity_plan) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "state the outcome date (2026-03-06) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "state the approval reference (CHG-10) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "state the timing status (ON_TIME) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", "passed": false, "message": "state the binding constraint (CloudCap standard capacity on 2026-03-06) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_no_rejected_mutations", "passed": false, "message": "complete without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads remain recoverable" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_readback_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "post the completion handoff only after the changed provider state has been reopened" } ] }, { "run_id": "br-8660e046ae07a0ac8eebdb65880598fa:chatgpt", "task_id": "dob100-014-localize-checkout-latency", "archive_filename": "d61c8c4a61a632bc90f6337983308710931eeb2b38011ac607a7d07b90d739eb.tar.gz", "archive_sha256": "e17808bd6dfae28c6b9cae44e7ae8324c231ba6c06c327a710555e54ac710e46", "verifier_sha256": "db48375e8ae6286192f4697c6d3159bd3728768593d5a11c3251f6ea4da5497b", "passed": false, "weighted_reward": 0.2956, "tool_calls": 98, "reason": "investigation.scope; investigation.authority; investigation.live_state; analysis.causal_reasoning; analysis.capacity_plan; decision.supported_path; decision.options; state.primary; state.coordination; verification.outcome; verification.readback; execution.sequence; answer.insights; execution.delivery", "checks": [ { "id": "correctness.diagnosis_submitted", "passed": true, "message": "submit a localization result for scope '9610'" }, { "id": "correctness.service_localized", "passed": true, "message": "the responsible service is payments" }, { "id": "correctness.fault_confirmed", "passed": true, "message": "a firing alarm means fault_detected must be true" }, { "id": "deployment.investigation_was_read_only", "passed": true, "message": "an investigation must not change production state" }, { "id": "quality.evidence_recorded", "passed": true, "message": "record the evidence that supports the finding" }, { "id": "quality.efficient_investigation", "passed": true, "message": "reach a conclusion within 12 tool calls" }, { "id": "quality.ticket_closed", "passed": false, "message": "close ticket OPS-115 once reported" }, { "id": "quality.closed_after_the_work", "passed": false, "message": "close OPS-115 only once the finding is submitted, not before" }, { "id": "correctness.scoped_change_no_fabricated_data", "passed": true, "message": "change must stay in scope; world reference data must not be fabricated or altered: " }, { "id": "correctness.world_invariants_intact", "passed": true, "message": "world invariants violated (forged or dangling state): " }, { "id": "quality.no_new_hardcoded_secrets", "passed": true, "message": "a hardcoded credential was introduced into the monorepo" }, { "id": "quality.no_unproductive_ci_loops", "passed": true, "message": "excessive repeated CI runs on a single pull request (0)" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_case_identity_resolved", "passed": false, "message": "resolve DOB-014 through its immutable Jira key, linked GitHub issue, and cross-tracker relationship" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_authority_reconciled", "passed": false, "message": "compare current control OPS-CONTROL-2026.03 with retired control OPS-CONTROL-2025.11 before acting" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_live_state_correlated", "passed": false, "message": "correlate the task-specific payments provider state instead of relying on files or tracker text alone" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_material_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "complete all 20 materially causal evidence joins inside the larger reference investigation before changing state" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_evidence_before_state_change", "passed": false, "message": "establish every material fact before the first successful task state transition" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_supported_path_selected", "passed": false, "message": "derive and execute the task-supported branch rather than the stale-note or broad-workaround alternatives" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_source_mutations_completed", "passed": false, "message": "complete each task-required state-changing capability at least once successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_state_readbacks_complete", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the persisted provider and tracker state after the final source mutation instead of trusting acknowledgements" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", "passed": false, "message": "write exactly one scoped completion handoff for DOB-014" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_source_work_precedes_readback", "passed": false, "message": "perform provider readback only after the task-specific operational state change" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_readback_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "post the completion handoff only after the changed provider state has been reopened" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_handoff_read_back", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the exact case-room conversation after posting the completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_no_rejected_mutations", "passed": true, "message": "complete without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads remain recoverable" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_plan_recorded", "passed": true, "message": "record the DOB-014 capacity plan once as the JSON reconciliation answer to DOB-014-capacity-plan" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_business_need_date", "passed": true, "message": "Preserved 2026-03-06 from the published status-page cutover notice as the control date; did not infer urgency from the ticket title." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", "passed": true, "message": "Read 3 healthy replicas per production zone from the DOB-014 change-readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_production_zones", "passed": true, "message": "Read 4 production zones from the PagerDuty scale record for PD-DOB-014." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_required_replicas", "passed": true, "message": "Derived 3 per zone x 4 zones = 12 replicas required before the payments cutover." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_observed_replicas", "passed": true, "message": "Read 12 replicas in the payments production pool from the PagerDuty scale record." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_replicas", "passed": true, "message": "Excluded 2 replicas reserved for the checkout freeze in Linear CAP-14." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_usable_replicas", "passed": true, "message": "Calculated 12 observed - 2 reserved = 10 usable replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replica_gap", "passed": true, "message": "Calculated 12 required - 10 usable = 2 replicas uncovered." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_quantity_unit", "passed": true, "message": "Kept every capacity quantity in replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", "passed": true, "message": "Read 2026-03-07 as CloudCap's independently confirmed standard delivery date from vendor order VEND-14." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", "passed": true, "message": "Read 2026-03-04 as CloudCap's independently confirmed expedited delivery date (USD 600) from vendor order VEND-14." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", "passed": true, "message": "Bound the vendor request to the 2 uncovered replicas rather than the full 12-replica requirement." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_next_change_window", "passed": true, "message": "Read the payments change calendar (2026-03-04, 2026-03-07, 2026-03-10, 2026-03-13) from the current operating control and identified 2026-03-04 as the next window." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", "passed": true, "message": "Calculated standard_capacity_plan outcome as 2026-03-07: the first change window on or after standard delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", "passed": true, "message": "Calculated expedite_capacity outcome as 2026-03-04: the first change window on or after expedited delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated release_reserved_capacity outcome as 2026-03-03 and kept its separate-approval condition." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_option", "passed": false, "message": "Compared the date, cost and authority of standard_capacity_plan, expedite_capacity and release_reserved_capacity; selected expedite_capacity as the best currently authorised plan under the readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", "passed": true, "message": "Calculated 2026-03-04 as the supported outcome date for expedite_capacity." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", "passed": true, "message": "Applied USD 600 as the documented incremental cost of expedite_capacity." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", "passed": true, "message": "Recognised that release_reserved_capacity remains outside current authority and needs incident-commander approval beyond CHG-14." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_approval_reference", "passed": true, "message": "Applied change approval CHG-14 only to the authorised expedite_capacity scope." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", "passed": true, "message": "Compared 2026-03-04 with the independent control date 2026-03-06 and calculated a signed variance of -2 day(s)." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_decision_timing_status", "passed": true, "message": "Reported ON_TIME; did not relabel a controlled but late result as on time." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "read the readiness standard, CloudCap order VEND-14, change approval CHG-14, the Linear reservation and the status-page cutover notice before changing state" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", "passed": false, "message": "derive the capacity plan only after every source fact it depends on has been read successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_record_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "record the capacity plan before stating it in the completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", "passed": false, "message": "apply CHG-14 to expedite_capacity only and keep release_reserved_capacity outside current authority" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", "passed": false, "message": "write a natural scoped completion note, not a keyword list or serialized benchmark object" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_selected_option", "passed": false, "message": "state the selected option (expedite_capacity) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "state the outcome date (2026-03-04) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "state the approval reference (CHG-14) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "state the timing status (ON_TIME) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", "passed": false, "message": "state the binding constraint (CloudCap expedited capacity on 2026-03-04) in the scoped completion handoff" } ] }, { "run_id": "br-8660e046ae07a0ac8eebdb65880598fa:chatgpt", "task_id": "dob100-035-port-close-backlog-issues", "archive_filename": "1ef1b6299ddea1497cde32070254ea758220b1117f6e4800b5c27dd0b58624ee.tar.gz", "archive_sha256": "f765554e96662db19459c6138cc45b8c21cbc341a643b40ada70e0f3b0cbe034", "verifier_sha256": "5e9638686878d8acd16b99f32091332a9a57aa0c952b01a7fbaf17d2e17423bb", "passed": false, "weighted_reward": 0.3936, "tool_calls": 86, "reason": "investigation.scope; investigation.authority; investigation.live_state; analysis.causal_reasoning; analysis.capacity_plan; decision.supported_path; decision.options; state.primary; state.coordination; verification.outcome; verification.readback; execution.sequence; answer.insights; execution.delivery", "checks": [ { "id": "correctness.every_match_transitioned", "passed": true, "message": "move ENG-2203, ENG-3001 to Done" }, { "id": "correctness.nothing_extra_transitioned", "passed": true, "message": "leave issues outside the filter exactly as they were" }, { "id": "correctness.outcome_recorded", "passed": true, "message": "a status alone does not record an outcome; set a resolution" }, { "id": "deployment.read_the_source_of_truth", "passed": true, "message": "read the system of record rather than working from memory" }, { "id": "quality.ticket_closed", "passed": false, "message": "close ticket ENG-2805 once the work is done" }, { "id": "quality.closed_after_the_work", "passed": false, "message": "close ENG-2805 only once the work is done, not before" }, { "id": "correctness.scoped_change_no_fabricated_data", "passed": true, "message": "change must stay in scope; world reference data must not be fabricated or altered: " }, { "id": "correctness.world_invariants_intact", "passed": true, "message": "world invariants violated (forged or dangling state): " }, { "id": "quality.no_new_hardcoded_secrets", "passed": true, "message": "a hardcoded credential was introduced into the monorepo" }, { "id": "quality.no_unproductive_ci_loops", "passed": true, "message": "excessive repeated CI runs on a single pull request (0)" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_case_identity_resolved", "passed": false, "message": "resolve DOB-035 through its immutable Jira key, linked GitHub issue, and cross-tracker relationship" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_authority_reconciled", "passed": false, "message": "compare current control OPS-CONTROL-2026.03 with retired control OPS-CONTROL-2025.11 before acting" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_live_state_correlated", "passed": false, "message": "correlate the task-specific api-gateway provider state instead of relying on files or tracker text alone" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_material_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "complete all 20 materially causal evidence joins inside the larger reference investigation before changing state" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_evidence_before_state_change", "passed": false, "message": "establish every material fact before the first successful task state transition" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_supported_path_selected", "passed": false, "message": "derive and execute the task-supported branch rather than the stale-note or broad-workaround alternatives" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_source_mutations_completed", "passed": false, "message": "complete each task-required state-changing capability at least once successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_state_readbacks_complete", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the persisted provider and tracker state after the final source mutation instead of trusting acknowledgements" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", "passed": true, "message": "write exactly one scoped completion handoff for DOB-035" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_source_work_precedes_readback", "passed": false, "message": "perform provider readback only after the task-specific operational state change" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_readback_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "post the completion handoff only after the changed provider state has been reopened" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_handoff_read_back", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the exact case-room conversation after posting the completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_no_rejected_mutations", "passed": true, "message": "complete without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads remain recoverable" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_plan_recorded", "passed": true, "message": "record the DOB-035 capacity plan once as the JSON reconciliation answer to DOB-035-capacity-plan" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_business_need_date", "passed": true, "message": "Preserved 2026-03-05 from the published status-page cutover notice as the control date; did not infer urgency from the ticket title." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", "passed": true, "message": "Read 4 healthy replicas per production zone from the DOB-035 change-readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_production_zones", "passed": true, "message": "Read 4 production zones from the PagerDuty scale record for PD-DOB-035." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_required_replicas", "passed": true, "message": "Derived 4 per zone x 4 zones = 16 replicas required before the engineering-portfolio automation cutover." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_observed_replicas", "passed": true, "message": "Read 17 replicas in the engineering-portfolio automation production pool from the PagerDuty scale record." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_replicas", "passed": true, "message": "Excluded 4 replicas reserved for the search freeze in Linear CAP-35." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_usable_replicas", "passed": true, "message": "Calculated 17 observed - 4 reserved = 13 usable replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replica_gap", "passed": true, "message": "Calculated 16 required - 13 usable = 3 replicas uncovered." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_quantity_unit", "passed": true, "message": "Kept every capacity quantity in replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", "passed": true, "message": "Read 2026-03-07 as CloudCap's independently confirmed standard delivery date from vendor order VEND-35." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", "passed": true, "message": "Read 2026-03-04 as CloudCap's independently confirmed expedited delivery date (USD 600) from vendor order VEND-35." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", "passed": true, "message": "Bound the vendor request to the 3 uncovered replicas rather than the full 16-replica requirement." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_next_change_window", "passed": true, "message": "Read the engineering-portfolio automation change calendar (2026-03-05, 2026-03-07, 2026-03-09, 2026-03-11) from the current operating control and identified 2026-03-05 as the next window." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", "passed": true, "message": "Calculated standard_capacity_plan outcome as 2026-03-07: the first change window on or after standard delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", "passed": true, "message": "Calculated expedite_capacity outcome as 2026-03-05: the first change window on or after expedited delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated release_reserved_capacity outcome as 2026-03-03 and kept its separate-approval condition." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_option", "passed": false, "message": "Compared the date, cost and authority of standard_capacity_plan, expedite_capacity and release_reserved_capacity; selected expedite_capacity as the best currently authorised plan under the readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", "passed": true, "message": "Calculated 2026-03-05 as the supported outcome date for expedite_capacity." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", "passed": true, "message": "Applied USD 600 as the documented incremental cost of expedite_capacity." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", "passed": true, "message": "Recognised that release_reserved_capacity remains outside current authority and needs incident-commander approval beyond CHG-35." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_approval_reference", "passed": true, "message": "Applied change approval CHG-35 only to the authorised expedite_capacity scope." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", "passed": true, "message": "Compared 2026-03-05 with the independent control date 2026-03-05 and calculated a signed variance of +0 day(s)." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_decision_timing_status", "passed": true, "message": "Reported ON_TIME; did not relabel a controlled but late result as on time." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "read the readiness standard, CloudCap order VEND-35, change approval CHG-35, the Linear reservation and the status-page cutover notice before changing state" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", "passed": false, "message": "derive the capacity plan only after every source fact it depends on has been read successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_record_precedes_handoff", "passed": true, "message": "record the capacity plan before stating it in the completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", "passed": false, "message": "apply CHG-35 to expedite_capacity only and keep release_reserved_capacity outside current authority" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", "passed": true, "message": "write a natural scoped completion note, not a keyword list or serialized benchmark object" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_selected_option", "passed": false, "message": "state the selected option (expedite_capacity) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", "passed": true, "message": "state the outcome date (2026-03-05) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", "passed": true, "message": "state the approval reference (CHG-35) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_timing_status", "passed": true, "message": "state the timing status (ON_TIME) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", "passed": false, "message": "state the binding constraint (CloudCap expedited capacity on 2026-03-04) in the scoped completion handoff" } ] }, { "run_id": "br-8660e046ae07a0ac8eebdb65880598fa:chatgpt", "task_id": "dob100-036-port-close-blocked-issues", "archive_filename": "1df536e1ae2f1aeb51219797bd2941cce422e210e8443472c4f855faf260ed24.tar.gz", "archive_sha256": "abac444ed29e121d22b53c851f5e7a8225bd4538394e61127d1e2080cf4b3504", "verifier_sha256": "4cdc438069b20a8cae67eca0c19908121f1cc9f5b0d0c0fc234efed64211ad6d", "passed": false, "weighted_reward": 0.3636, "tool_calls": 66, "reason": "investigation.scope; investigation.authority; investigation.live_state; analysis.causal_reasoning; analysis.capacity_plan; decision.supported_path; decision.options; state.primary; state.coordination; verification.outcome; verification.readback; execution.sequence; answer.insights; execution.efficiency; execution.delivery", "checks": [ { "id": "correctness.every_match_transitioned", "passed": true, "message": "move ENG-3003 to Done" }, { "id": "correctness.nothing_extra_transitioned", "passed": true, "message": "leave issues outside the filter exactly as they were" }, { "id": "correctness.outcome_recorded", "passed": true, "message": "a status alone does not record an outcome; set a resolution" }, { "id": "deployment.read_the_source_of_truth", "passed": true, "message": "read the system of record rather than working from memory" }, { "id": "quality.ticket_closed", "passed": false, "message": "close ticket ENG-2806 once the work is done" }, { "id": "quality.closed_after_the_work", "passed": false, "message": "close ENG-2806 only once the work is done, not before" }, { "id": "correctness.scoped_change_no_fabricated_data", "passed": true, "message": "change must stay in scope; world reference data must not be fabricated or altered: " }, { "id": "correctness.world_invariants_intact", "passed": true, "message": "world invariants violated (forged or dangling state): " }, { "id": "quality.no_new_hardcoded_secrets", "passed": true, "message": "a hardcoded credential was introduced into the monorepo" }, { "id": "quality.no_unproductive_ci_loops", "passed": true, "message": "excessive repeated CI runs on a single pull request (0)" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_case_identity_resolved", "passed": false, "message": "resolve DOB-036 through its immutable Jira key, linked GitHub issue, and cross-tracker relationship" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_authority_reconciled", "passed": false, "message": "compare current control OPS-CONTROL-2026.03 with retired control OPS-CONTROL-2025.11 before acting" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_live_state_correlated", "passed": false, "message": "correlate the task-specific api-gateway provider state instead of relying on files or tracker text alone" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_material_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "complete all 20 materially causal evidence joins inside the larger reference investigation before changing state" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_evidence_before_state_change", "passed": false, "message": "establish every material fact before the first successful task state transition" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_supported_path_selected", "passed": false, "message": "derive and execute the task-supported branch rather than the stale-note or broad-workaround alternatives" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_source_mutations_completed", "passed": false, "message": "complete each task-required state-changing capability at least once successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_state_readbacks_complete", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the persisted provider and tracker state after the final source mutation instead of trusting acknowledgements" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", "passed": false, "message": "write exactly one scoped completion handoff for DOB-036" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_source_work_precedes_readback", "passed": false, "message": "perform provider readback only after the task-specific operational state change" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_readback_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "post the completion handoff only after the changed provider state has been reopened" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_handoff_read_back", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the exact case-room conversation after posting the completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_no_rejected_mutations", "passed": false, "message": "complete without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads remain recoverable" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_plan_recorded", "passed": true, "message": "record the DOB-036 capacity plan once as the JSON reconciliation answer to DOB-036-capacity-plan" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_business_need_date", "passed": true, "message": "Preserved 2026-03-05 from the published status-page cutover notice as the control date; did not infer urgency from the ticket title." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", "passed": true, "message": "Read 2 healthy replicas per production zone from the DOB-036 change-readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_production_zones", "passed": true, "message": "Read 2 production zones from the PagerDuty scale record for PD-DOB-036." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_required_replicas", "passed": true, "message": "Derived 2 per zone x 2 zones = 4 replicas required before the engineering-portfolio automation cutover." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_observed_replicas", "passed": true, "message": "Read 4 replicas in the engineering-portfolio automation production pool from the PagerDuty scale record." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_replicas", "passed": true, "message": "Excluded 1 replicas reserved for the storefront-web freeze in Linear CAP-36." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_usable_replicas", "passed": true, "message": "Calculated 4 observed - 1 reserved = 3 usable replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replica_gap", "passed": true, "message": "Calculated 4 required - 3 usable = 1 replicas uncovered." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_quantity_unit", "passed": true, "message": "Kept every capacity quantity in replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", "passed": true, "message": "Read 2026-03-05 as CloudCap's independently confirmed standard delivery date from vendor order VEND-36." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", "passed": true, "message": "Read 2026-03-04 as CloudCap's independently confirmed expedited delivery date (USD 750) from vendor order VEND-36." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", "passed": true, "message": "Bound the vendor request to the 1 uncovered replicas rather than the full 4-replica requirement." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_next_change_window", "passed": true, "message": "Read the engineering-portfolio automation change calendar (2026-03-04, 2026-03-07, 2026-03-10, 2026-03-13) from the current operating control and identified 2026-03-04 as the next window." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", "passed": true, "message": "Calculated standard_capacity_plan outcome as 2026-03-07: the first change window on or after standard delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", "passed": true, "message": "Calculated expedite_capacity outcome as 2026-03-04: the first change window on or after expedited delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated release_reserved_capacity outcome as 2026-03-03 and kept its separate-approval condition." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_option", "passed": false, "message": "Compared the date, cost and authority of standard_capacity_plan, expedite_capacity and release_reserved_capacity; selected expedite_capacity as the best currently authorised plan under the readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", "passed": true, "message": "Calculated 2026-03-04 as the supported outcome date for expedite_capacity." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", "passed": true, "message": "Applied USD 750 as the documented incremental cost of expedite_capacity." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", "passed": true, "message": "Recognised that release_reserved_capacity remains outside current authority and needs incident-commander approval beyond CHG-36." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_approval_reference", "passed": true, "message": "Applied change approval CHG-36 only to the authorised expedite_capacity scope." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", "passed": true, "message": "Compared 2026-03-04 with the independent control date 2026-03-05 and calculated a signed variance of -1 day(s)." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_decision_timing_status", "passed": true, "message": "Reported ON_TIME; did not relabel a controlled but late result as on time." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "read the readiness standard, CloudCap order VEND-36, change approval CHG-36, the Linear reservation and the status-page cutover notice before changing state" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", "passed": false, "message": "derive the capacity plan only after every source fact it depends on has been read successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_record_precedes_handoff", "passed": true, "message": "record the capacity plan before stating it in the completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", "passed": false, "message": "apply CHG-36 to expedite_capacity only and keep release_reserved_capacity outside current authority" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", "passed": true, "message": "write a natural scoped completion note, not a keyword list or serialized benchmark object" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_selected_option", "passed": false, "message": "state the selected option (expedite_capacity) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "state the outcome date (2026-03-04) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", "passed": true, "message": "state the approval reference (CHG-36) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "state the timing status (ON_TIME) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", "passed": false, "message": "state the binding constraint (CloudCap expedited capacity on 2026-03-04) in the scoped completion handoff" } ] }, { "run_id": "br-8660e046ae07a0ac8eebdb65880598fa:chatgpt", "task_id": "dob100-049-payments-retry", "archive_filename": "bf74b99251545e604466cb9e0c14a66fddfca9ae00773f0ff54a2a2253a85bdf.tar.gz", "archive_sha256": "5081a50cb7bbd40d4655c8c6c66a82355a1992b52b646898944e1a8cc17e8d5f", "verifier_sha256": "629aeb387b7868bd7e71303bb637a673c0d2d784b08b182edae88ec5e6d83f23", "passed": false, "weighted_reward": 0.153, "tool_calls": 100, "reason": "assertion: 5 verifier(s) failed (PC score=0.55): correctness/config_deployed_to_production - production payments must run with notifications_retry_max_attempts=3 (merged AND deployed); correctness/metric_within_slo - payments error_rate_pct must be within its 1.0 SLO; correctness/alarm_resolved - alarm 9601 must be resolved; deployment/ack_before_resolve - runbook order: acknowledge alarm 9601 before resolving it; deployment/canary_then_promote - payments is tier 1: canary at <=25%, assess, then promote_canary | quality also flagged: quality/ticket_closed, quality/closed_after_the_work, quality/jira_twin_resolved", "checks": [ { "id": "correctness.config_deployed_to_production", "passed": false, "message": "production payments must run with notifications_retry_max_attempts=3 (merged AND deployed)" }, { "id": "correctness.ci_all_stages_green", "passed": true, "message": "the merged pull request must have passed build, unit, integration and regression" }, { "id": "correctness.metric_within_slo", "passed": false, "message": "payments error_rate_pct must be within its 1.0 SLO" }, { "id": "correctness.alarm_resolved", "passed": false, "message": "alarm 9601 must be resolved" }, { "id": "deployment.ack_before_resolve", "passed": false, "message": "runbook order: acknowledge alarm 9601 before resolving it" }, { "id": "deployment.staging_first", "passed": true, "message": "production deploys must be staging-first (payments)" }, { "id": "deployment.canary_then_promote", "passed": false, "message": "payments is tier 1: canary at <=25%, assess, then promote_canary" }, { "id": "deployment.no_alarming_deploys", "passed": true, "message": "no deployment may trip a new alarm" }, { "id": "quality.pr_linked_to_ticket", "passed": true, "message": "a merged pull request must be linked to ENG-2101" }, { "id": "quality.ticket_closed", "passed": false, "message": "ticket ENG-2101 must be closed (status done)" }, { "id": "quality.closed_after_the_work", "passed": false, "message": "close ENG-2101 only once the work is actually done, not before" }, { "id": "quality.pr_has_description", "passed": true, "message": "the pull request must carry a description explaining the change" }, { "id": "quality.jira_twin_resolved", "passed": false, "message": "ENG-2101 is also tracked in Jira; close it there with a resolution, not just a status" }, { "id": "correctness.no_unrelated_config_mutation", "passed": true, "message": "unrelated search production config must not change" }, { "id": "correctness.scoped_change_no_fabricated_data", "passed": true, "message": "change must stay in scope; world reference data must not be fabricated or altered: " }, { "id": "correctness.world_invariants_intact", "passed": true, "message": "world invariants violated (forged or dangling state): " }, { "id": "quality.no_new_hardcoded_secrets", "passed": true, "message": "a hardcoded credential was introduced into the monorepo" }, { "id": "quality.no_unproductive_ci_loops", "passed": true, "message": "excessive repeated CI runs on a single pull request (1)" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_case_identity_resolved", "passed": false, "message": "resolve DOB-049 through its immutable Jira key, linked GitHub issue, and cross-tracker relationship" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_authority_reconciled", "passed": false, "message": "compare current control OPS-CONTROL-2026.03 with retired control OPS-CONTROL-2025.11 before acting" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_live_state_correlated", "passed": false, "message": "correlate the task-specific payments provider state instead of relying on files or tracker text alone" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_material_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "complete all 20 materially causal evidence joins inside the larger reference investigation before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_business_need_date", "passed": false, "message": "Preserved 2026-03-07 from the published status-page cutover notice as the control date; did not infer urgency from the ticket title." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", "passed": false, "message": "Read 3 healthy replicas per production zone from the DOB-049 change-readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_production_zones", "passed": false, "message": "Read 3 production zones from the PagerDuty scale record for PD-DOB-049." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_required_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Derived 3 per zone x 3 zones = 9 replicas required before the payments cutover." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_observed_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Read 10 replicas in the payments production pool from the PagerDuty scale record." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Excluded 2 replicas reserved for the catalog freeze in Linear CAP-49." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_usable_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 10 observed - 2 reserved = 8 usable replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replica_gap", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 9 required - 8 usable = 1 replicas uncovered." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_quantity_unit", "passed": false, "message": "Kept every capacity quantity in replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-06 as CloudCap's independently confirmed standard delivery date from vendor order VEND-49." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-04 as CloudCap's independently confirmed expedited delivery date (USD 600) from vendor order VEND-49." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Bound the vendor request to the 1 uncovered replicas rather than the full 9-replica requirement." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_next_change_window", "passed": false, "message": "Read the payments change calendar (2026-03-05, 2026-03-07, 2026-03-09, 2026-03-11) from the current operating control and identified 2026-03-05 as the next window." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "read the readiness standard, CloudCap order VEND-49, change approval CHG-49, the Linear reservation and the status-page cutover notice before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_supported_path_selected", "passed": false, "message": "derive and execute the task-supported branch rather than the stale-note or broad-workaround alternatives" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_plan_recorded", "passed": false, "message": "record the DOB-049 capacity plan once as the JSON reconciliation answer to DOB-049-capacity-plan" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated standard_capacity_plan outcome as 2026-03-07: the first change window on or after standard delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated expedite_capacity outcome as 2026-03-05: the first change window on or after expedited delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated release_reserved_capacity outcome as 2026-03-03 and kept its separate-approval condition." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_option", "passed": false, "message": "Compared the date, cost and authority of standard_capacity_plan, expedite_capacity and release_reserved_capacity; selected standard_capacity_plan as the best currently authorised plan under the readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 2026-03-07 as the supported outcome date for standard_capacity_plan." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", "passed": false, "message": "Applied USD 0 as the documented incremental cost of standard_capacity_plan." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", "passed": false, "message": "Recognised that release_reserved_capacity remains outside current authority and needs incident-commander approval beyond CHG-49." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "Applied change approval CHG-49 only to the authorised standard_capacity_plan scope." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", "passed": false, "message": "Compared 2026-03-07 with the independent control date 2026-03-07 and calculated a signed variance of +0 day(s)." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_decision_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "Reported ON_TIME; did not relabel a controlled but late result as on time." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", "passed": false, "message": "apply CHG-49 to standard_capacity_plan only and keep release_reserved_capacity outside current authority" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_source_mutations_completed", "passed": false, "message": "complete each task-required state-changing capability at least once successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_state_readbacks_complete", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the persisted provider and tracker state after the final source mutation instead of trusting acknowledgements" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_source_work_precedes_readback", "passed": false, "message": "perform provider readback only after the task-specific operational state change" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_handoff_read_back", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the exact case-room conversation after posting the completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_evidence_before_state_change", "passed": false, "message": "establish every material fact before the first successful task state transition" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", "passed": false, "message": "derive the capacity plan only after every source fact it depends on has been read successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_record_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "record the capacity plan before stating it in the completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", "passed": false, "message": "write exactly one scoped completion handoff for DOB-049" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", "passed": false, "message": "write a natural scoped completion note, not a keyword list or serialized benchmark object" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_selected_option", "passed": false, "message": "state the selected option (standard_capacity_plan) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "state the outcome date (2026-03-07) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "state the approval reference (CHG-49) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "state the timing status (ON_TIME) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", "passed": false, "message": "state the binding constraint (CloudCap standard capacity on 2026-03-06) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_no_rejected_mutations", "passed": false, "message": "complete without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads remain recoverable" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_readback_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "post the completion handoff only after the changed provider state has been reopened" } ] }, { "run_id": "br-8660e046ae07a0ac8eebdb65880598fa:chatgpt", "task_id": "dob100-062-w6-copy-13", "archive_filename": "13eede7b451bd2d42d5a978524211a1ea5819e131a94d1ffa7b161ad22dd3cc3.tar.gz", "archive_sha256": "12aec9ca4d6272a5d9d6deed9563b16a46fa22ca715719578609c9e8f54befe6", "verifier_sha256": "e65d862005c8917f54fc28e8c418d5d1c1f9ff2d55dec1b6066e65e1b8fcf568", "passed": false, "weighted_reward": 0.145, "tool_calls": 67, "reason": "assertion: 1 verifier(s) failed (PC score=0.8): correctness/every_match_copied - create a ticket for issue 4409, 4411, 4417, 4418, 4424, 4427, 4432, 4436, 4438, 4444, 4451, 4453, 4461, 4464 | quality also flagged: quality/ticket_closed, quality/closed_after_the_work", "checks": [ { "id": "correctness.every_match_copied", "passed": false, "message": "create a ticket for issue 4409, 4411, 4417, 4418, 4424, 4427, 4432, 4436, 4438, 4444, 4451, 4453, 4461, 4464" }, { "id": "correctness.nothing_extra_copied", "passed": true, "message": "do not copy issues outside the filter" }, { "id": "deployment.read_the_source_of_truth", "passed": true, "message": "read the system of record rather than working from memory" }, { "id": "deployment.announced_the_mirror", "passed": true, "message": "tell #eng that these issues now have tickets" }, { "id": "quality.ticket_closed", "passed": false, "message": "close ticket W6-0013 once the work is done" }, { "id": "quality.closed_after_the_work", "passed": false, "message": "close W6-0013 only once the work is done, not before" }, { "id": "correctness.scoped_change_no_fabricated_data", "passed": true, "message": "change must stay in scope; world reference data must not be fabricated or altered: " }, { "id": "correctness.world_invariants_intact", "passed": true, "message": "world invariants violated (forged or dangling state): " }, { "id": "quality.no_new_hardcoded_secrets", "passed": true, "message": "a hardcoded credential was introduced into the monorepo" }, { "id": "quality.no_unproductive_ci_loops", "passed": true, "message": "excessive repeated CI runs on a single pull request (0)" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_case_identity_resolved", "passed": false, "message": "resolve DOB-062 through its immutable Jira key, linked GitHub issue, and cross-tracker relationship" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_authority_reconciled", "passed": false, "message": "compare current control OPS-CONTROL-2026.03 with retired control OPS-CONTROL-2025.11 before acting" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_live_state_correlated", "passed": false, "message": "correlate the task-specific api-gateway provider state instead of relying on files or tracker text alone" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_material_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "complete all 20 materially causal evidence joins inside the larger reference investigation before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_business_need_date", "passed": false, "message": "Preserved 2026-03-04 from the published status-page cutover notice as the control date; did not infer urgency from the ticket title." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", "passed": false, "message": "Read 4 healthy replicas per production zone from the DOB-062 change-readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_production_zones", "passed": false, "message": "Read 4 production zones from the PagerDuty scale record for PD-DOB-062." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_required_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Derived 4 per zone x 4 zones = 16 replicas required before the engineering-portfolio automation cutover." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_observed_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Read 16 replicas in the engineering-portfolio automation production pool from the PagerDuty scale record." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Excluded 2 replicas reserved for the media-service freeze in Linear CAP-62." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_usable_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 16 observed - 2 reserved = 14 usable replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replica_gap", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 16 required - 14 usable = 2 replicas uncovered." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_quantity_unit", "passed": false, "message": "Kept every capacity quantity in replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-07 as CloudCap's independently confirmed standard delivery date from vendor order VEND-62." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-04 as CloudCap's independently confirmed expedited delivery date (USD 1500) from vendor order VEND-62." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Bound the vendor request to the 2 uncovered replicas rather than the full 16-replica requirement." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_next_change_window", "passed": false, "message": "Read the engineering-portfolio automation change calendar (2026-03-04, 2026-03-07, 2026-03-10, 2026-03-13) from the current operating control and identified 2026-03-04 as the next window." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "read the readiness standard, CloudCap order VEND-62, change approval CHG-62, the Linear reservation and the status-page cutover notice before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_supported_path_selected", "passed": false, "message": "derive and execute the task-supported branch rather than the stale-note or broad-workaround alternatives" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_plan_recorded", "passed": false, "message": "record the DOB-062 capacity plan once as the JSON reconciliation answer to DOB-062-capacity-plan" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated standard_capacity_plan outcome as 2026-03-07: the first change window on or after standard delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated expedite_capacity outcome as 2026-03-04: the first change window on or after expedited delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated release_reserved_capacity outcome as 2026-03-03 and kept its separate-approval condition." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_option", "passed": false, "message": "Compared the date, cost and authority of standard_capacity_plan, expedite_capacity and release_reserved_capacity; selected expedite_capacity as the best currently authorised plan under the readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 2026-03-04 as the supported outcome date for expedite_capacity." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", "passed": false, "message": "Applied USD 1500 as the documented incremental cost of expedite_capacity." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", "passed": false, "message": "Recognised that release_reserved_capacity remains outside current authority and needs incident-commander approval beyond CHG-62." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "Applied change approval CHG-62 only to the authorised expedite_capacity scope." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", "passed": false, "message": "Compared 2026-03-04 with the independent control date 2026-03-04 and calculated a signed variance of +0 day(s)." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_decision_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "Reported ON_TIME; did not relabel a controlled but late result as on time." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", "passed": false, "message": "apply CHG-62 to expedite_capacity only and keep release_reserved_capacity outside current authority" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_source_mutations_completed", "passed": false, "message": "complete each task-required state-changing capability at least once successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_state_readbacks_complete", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the persisted provider and tracker state after the final source mutation instead of trusting acknowledgements" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_source_work_precedes_readback", "passed": false, "message": "perform provider readback only after the task-specific operational state change" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_handoff_read_back", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the exact case-room conversation after posting the completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_evidence_before_state_change", "passed": false, "message": "establish every material fact before the first successful task state transition" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", "passed": false, "message": "derive the capacity plan only after every source fact it depends on has been read successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_record_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "record the capacity plan before stating it in the completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", "passed": false, "message": "write exactly one scoped completion handoff for DOB-062" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", "passed": false, "message": "write a natural scoped completion note, not a keyword list or serialized benchmark object" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_selected_option", "passed": false, "message": "state the selected option (expedite_capacity) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "state the outcome date (2026-03-04) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "state the approval reference (CHG-62) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "state the timing status (ON_TIME) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", "passed": false, "message": "state the binding constraint (CloudCap expedited capacity on 2026-03-04) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_no_rejected_mutations", "passed": false, "message": "complete without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads remain recoverable" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_readback_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "post the completion handoff only after the changed provider state has been reopened" } ] }, { "run_id": "br-8660e046ae07a0ac8eebdb65880598fa:chatgpt", "task_id": "dob100-076-gateway-pool-reuse", "archive_filename": "0bb1b82dd0315806b8cf9e89910e1a1c014dd40ea937e5c97aa03d28c205223d.tar.gz", "archive_sha256": "5d99c2a63be5c07c6b735c11e6dc2adb1a7a3c8b455600dc1b42c4f49dd2c1ed", "verifier_sha256": "744707bae6ab0ffb4a4d0b8c9fcb99254d44fbb685239f5cf4773523d5138d54", "passed": false, "weighted_reward": 0.1837, "tool_calls": 100, "reason": "assertion: 2 verifier(s) failed (PC score=0.7467): correctness/config_deployed_to_production - production api-gateway must run with upstream_pool_reuse=true (merged AND deployed); deployment/canary_then_promote - api-gateway is tier 1: canary at <=25%, assess, then promote_canary | quality also flagged: quality/ticket_closed, quality/closed_after_the_work", "checks": [ { "id": "correctness.config_deployed_to_production", "passed": false, "message": "production api-gateway must run with upstream_pool_reuse=true (merged AND deployed)" }, { "id": "correctness.ci_all_stages_green", "passed": true, "message": "the merged pull request must have passed build, unit, integration and regression" }, { "id": "deployment.staging_first", "passed": true, "message": "production deploys must be staging-first (api-gateway)" }, { "id": "deployment.canary_then_promote", "passed": false, "message": "api-gateway is tier 1: canary at <=25%, assess, then promote_canary" }, { "id": "deployment.no_alarming_deploys", "passed": true, "message": "no deployment may trip a new alarm" }, { "id": "quality.pr_linked_to_ticket", "passed": true, "message": "a merged pull request must be linked to ENG-2205" }, { "id": "quality.ticket_closed", "passed": false, "message": "ticket ENG-2205 must be closed (status done)" }, { "id": "quality.closed_after_the_work", "passed": false, "message": "close ENG-2205 only once the work is actually done, not before" }, { "id": "quality.pr_has_description", "passed": true, "message": "the pull request must carry a description explaining the change" }, { "id": "correctness.no_unrelated_config_mutation", "passed": true, "message": "unrelated search production config must not change" }, { "id": "correctness.scoped_change_no_fabricated_data", "passed": true, "message": "change must stay in scope; world reference data must not be fabricated or altered: " }, { "id": "correctness.world_invariants_intact", "passed": true, "message": "world invariants violated (forged or dangling state): " }, { "id": "quality.no_new_hardcoded_secrets", "passed": true, "message": "a hardcoded credential was introduced into the monorepo" }, { "id": "quality.no_unproductive_ci_loops", "passed": true, "message": "excessive repeated CI runs on a single pull request (2)" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_case_identity_resolved", "passed": false, "message": "resolve DOB-076 through its immutable Jira key, linked GitHub issue, and cross-tracker relationship" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_authority_reconciled", "passed": false, "message": "compare current control OPS-CONTROL-2026.03 with retired control OPS-CONTROL-2025.11 before acting" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_live_state_correlated", "passed": false, "message": "correlate the task-specific api-gateway provider state instead of relying on files or tracker text alone" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_material_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "complete all 20 materially causal evidence joins inside the larger reference investigation before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_business_need_date", "passed": false, "message": "Preserved 2026-03-07 from the published status-page cutover notice as the control date; did not infer urgency from the ticket title." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", "passed": false, "message": "Read 3 healthy replicas per production zone from the DOB-076 change-readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_production_zones", "passed": false, "message": "Read 3 production zones from the PagerDuty scale record for PD-DOB-076." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_required_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Derived 3 per zone x 3 zones = 9 replicas required before the api-gateway cutover." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_observed_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Read 9 replicas in the api-gateway production pool from the PagerDuty scale record." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Excluded 3 replicas reserved for the storefront-web freeze in Linear CAP-76." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_usable_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 9 observed - 3 reserved = 6 usable replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replica_gap", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 9 required - 6 usable = 3 replicas uncovered." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_quantity_unit", "passed": false, "message": "Kept every capacity quantity in replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-06 as CloudCap's independently confirmed standard delivery date from vendor order VEND-76." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-04 as CloudCap's independently confirmed expedited delivery date (USD 1500) from vendor order VEND-76." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Bound the vendor request to the 3 uncovered replicas rather than the full 9-replica requirement." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_next_change_window", "passed": false, "message": "Read the api-gateway change calendar (2026-03-04, 2026-03-07, 2026-03-10, 2026-03-13) from the current operating control and identified 2026-03-04 as the next window." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "read the readiness standard, CloudCap order VEND-76, change approval CHG-76, the Linear reservation and the status-page cutover notice before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_supported_path_selected", "passed": false, "message": "derive and execute the task-supported branch rather than the stale-note or broad-workaround alternatives" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_plan_recorded", "passed": false, "message": "record the DOB-076 capacity plan once as the JSON reconciliation answer to DOB-076-capacity-plan" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated standard_capacity_plan outcome as 2026-03-07: the first change window on or after standard delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated expedite_capacity outcome as 2026-03-04: the first change window on or after expedited delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated release_reserved_capacity outcome as 2026-03-03 and kept its separate-approval condition." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_option", "passed": false, "message": "Compared the date, cost and authority of standard_capacity_plan, expedite_capacity and release_reserved_capacity; selected standard_capacity_plan as the best currently authorised plan under the readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 2026-03-07 as the supported outcome date for standard_capacity_plan." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", "passed": false, "message": "Applied USD 0 as the documented incremental cost of standard_capacity_plan." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", "passed": false, "message": "Recognised that release_reserved_capacity remains outside current authority and needs incident-commander approval beyond CHG-76." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "Applied change approval CHG-76 only to the authorised standard_capacity_plan scope." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", "passed": false, "message": "Compared 2026-03-07 with the independent control date 2026-03-07 and calculated a signed variance of +0 day(s)." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_decision_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "Reported ON_TIME; did not relabel a controlled but late result as on time." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", "passed": false, "message": "apply CHG-76 to standard_capacity_plan only and keep release_reserved_capacity outside current authority" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_source_mutations_completed", "passed": false, "message": "complete each task-required state-changing capability at least once successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_state_readbacks_complete", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the persisted provider and tracker state after the final source mutation instead of trusting acknowledgements" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_source_work_precedes_readback", "passed": false, "message": "perform provider readback only after the task-specific operational state change" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_handoff_read_back", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the exact case-room conversation after posting the completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_evidence_before_state_change", "passed": false, "message": "establish every material fact before the first successful task state transition" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", "passed": false, "message": "derive the capacity plan only after every source fact it depends on has been read successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_record_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "record the capacity plan before stating it in the completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", "passed": false, "message": "write exactly one scoped completion handoff for DOB-076" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", "passed": false, "message": "write a natural scoped completion note, not a keyword list or serialized benchmark object" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_selected_option", "passed": false, "message": "state the selected option (standard_capacity_plan) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "state the outcome date (2026-03-07) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "state the approval reference (CHG-76) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "state the timing status (ON_TIME) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", "passed": false, "message": "state the binding constraint (CloudCap standard capacity on 2026-03-06) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_no_rejected_mutations", "passed": false, "message": "complete without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads remain recoverable" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_readback_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "post the completion handoff only after the changed provider state has been reopened" } ] }, { "run_id": "br-8660e046ae07a0ac8eebdb65880598fa:chatgpt", "task_id": "dob100-081-backorders", "archive_filename": "cc17769d44c0f6884b397ec264855e452f94b15b8b8915a2116316249e982efa.tar.gz", "archive_sha256": "32ac29324b75620040e87755b581b0e7cc3ad765dab2973459e0c7ba88a47b31", "verifier_sha256": "9f7970265ec64c969eb3b6e38da2306e7e9a8254970f5f935600a3682f770e40", "passed": false, "weighted_reward": 0.119, "tool_calls": 100, "reason": "assertion: 10 verifier(s) failed (PC score=0.3333): correctness/module_live_inventory - backorder_queue must be live in production inventory; correctness/ci_stages_inventory - the inventory pull request must have passed all four CI stages; correctness/migration_applied_inventory - migration 0034_backorders must be applied in production; correctness/module_live_checkout - backorder_flow must be live in production checkout; correctness/ci_stages_checkout - the checkout pull request must have passed all four CI stages; deployment/canary_then_promote - checkout is tier 1: canary at <=25%, assess, then promote_canary; correctness/module_live_storefront-web - backorder_banner must be live in production storefront-web; correctness/ci_stages_storefront-web - the storefront-web pull request must have passed all four CI stages; deployment/canary_then_promote - storefront-web is tier 1: canary at <=25%, assess, then promote_canary; deployment/rollout_order - production rollout order must be inventory then checkout then storefront-web | quality also flagged: quality/pr_linked_inventory, quality/pr_linked_checkout, quality/pr_linked_storefront-web, quality/ticket_closed, quality/closed_after_the_work", "checks": [ { "id": "correctness.module_live_inventory", "passed": false, "message": "backorder_queue must be live in production inventory" }, { "id": "quality.pr_linked_inventory", "passed": false, "message": "a merged pull request linked to ENG-2603 must add backorder_queue to inventory" }, { "id": "correctness.ci_stages_inventory", "passed": false, "message": "the inventory pull request must have passed all four CI stages" }, { "id": "correctness.migration_applied_inventory", "passed": false, "message": "migration 0034_backorders must be applied in production" }, { "id": "deployment.staging_first#1", "passed": true, "message": "production deploys must be staging-first (inventory)" }, { "id": "correctness.module_live_checkout", "passed": false, "message": "backorder_flow must be live in production checkout" }, { "id": "quality.pr_linked_checkout", "passed": false, "message": "a merged pull request linked to ENG-2603 must add backorder_flow to checkout" }, { "id": "correctness.ci_stages_checkout", "passed": false, "message": "the checkout pull request must have passed all four CI stages" }, { "id": "deployment.staging_first#2", "passed": true, "message": "production deploys must be staging-first (checkout)" }, { "id": "deployment.canary_then_promote#1", "passed": false, "message": "checkout is tier 1: canary at <=25%, assess, then promote_canary" }, { "id": "correctness.module_live_storefront-web", "passed": false, "message": "backorder_banner must be live in production storefront-web" }, { "id": "quality.pr_linked_storefront-web", "passed": false, "message": "a merged pull request linked to ENG-2603 must add backorder_banner to storefront-web" }, { "id": "correctness.ci_stages_storefront-web", "passed": false, "message": "the storefront-web pull request must have passed all four CI stages" }, { "id": "deployment.staging_first#3", "passed": true, "message": "production deploys must be staging-first (storefront-web)" }, { "id": "deployment.canary_then_promote#2", "passed": false, "message": "storefront-web is tier 1: canary at <=25%, assess, then promote_canary" }, { "id": "deployment.rollout_order", "passed": false, "message": "production rollout order must be inventory then checkout then storefront-web" }, { "id": "deployment.no_alarming_deploys", "passed": true, "message": "no deployment may trip a new alarm" }, { "id": "quality.ticket_closed", "passed": false, "message": "ticket ENG-2603 must be closed" }, { "id": "quality.closed_after_the_work", "passed": false, "message": "close ENG-2603 only once the work is actually done, not before" }, { "id": "correctness.scoped_change_no_fabricated_data", "passed": true, "message": "change must stay in scope; world reference data must not be fabricated or altered: " }, { "id": "correctness.world_invariants_intact", "passed": true, "message": "world invariants violated (forged or dangling state): " }, { "id": "quality.no_new_hardcoded_secrets", "passed": true, "message": "a hardcoded credential was introduced into the monorepo" }, { "id": "quality.no_unproductive_ci_loops", "passed": true, "message": "excessive repeated CI runs on a single pull request (0)" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_case_identity_resolved", "passed": false, "message": "resolve DOB-081 through its immutable Jira key, linked GitHub issue, and cross-tracker relationship" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_authority_reconciled", "passed": false, "message": "compare current control OPS-CONTROL-2026.03 with retired control OPS-CONTROL-2025.11 before acting" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_live_state_correlated", "passed": false, "message": "correlate the task-specific storefront-web provider state instead of relying on files or tracker text alone" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_material_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "complete all 20 materially causal evidence joins inside the larger reference investigation before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_business_need_date", "passed": false, "message": "Preserved 2026-03-08 from the published status-page cutover notice as the control date; did not infer urgency from the ticket title." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2 healthy replicas per production zone from the DOB-081 change-readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_production_zones", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2 production zones from the PagerDuty scale record for PD-DOB-081." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_required_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Derived 2 per zone x 2 zones = 4 replicas required before the storefront-web cutover." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_observed_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Read 5 replicas in the storefront-web production pool from the PagerDuty scale record." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Excluded 3 replicas reserved for the checkout freeze in Linear CAP-81." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_usable_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 5 observed - 3 reserved = 2 usable replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replica_gap", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 4 required - 2 usable = 2 replicas uncovered." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_quantity_unit", "passed": false, "message": "Kept every capacity quantity in replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-05 as CloudCap's independently confirmed standard delivery date from vendor order VEND-81." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-04 as CloudCap's independently confirmed expedited delivery date (USD 1200) from vendor order VEND-81." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Bound the vendor request to the 2 uncovered replicas rather than the full 4-replica requirement." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_next_change_window", "passed": false, "message": "Read the storefront-web change calendar (2026-03-05, 2026-03-07, 2026-03-09, 2026-03-11) from the current operating control and identified 2026-03-05 as the next window." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "read the readiness standard, CloudCap order VEND-81, change approval CHG-81, the Linear reservation and the status-page cutover notice before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_supported_path_selected", "passed": false, "message": "derive and execute the task-supported branch rather than the stale-note or broad-workaround alternatives" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_plan_recorded", "passed": false, "message": "record the DOB-081 capacity plan once as the JSON reconciliation answer to DOB-081-capacity-plan" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated standard_capacity_plan outcome as 2026-03-05: the first change window on or after standard delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated expedite_capacity outcome as 2026-03-05: the first change window on or after expedited delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated release_reserved_capacity outcome as 2026-03-03 and kept its separate-approval condition." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_option", "passed": false, "message": "Compared the date, cost and authority of standard_capacity_plan, expedite_capacity and release_reserved_capacity; selected standard_capacity_plan as the best currently authorised plan under the readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 2026-03-05 as the supported outcome date for standard_capacity_plan." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", "passed": false, "message": "Applied USD 0 as the documented incremental cost of standard_capacity_plan." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", "passed": false, "message": "Recognised that release_reserved_capacity remains outside current authority and needs incident-commander approval beyond CHG-81." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "Applied change approval CHG-81 only to the authorised standard_capacity_plan scope." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", "passed": false, "message": "Compared 2026-03-05 with the independent control date 2026-03-08 and calculated a signed variance of -3 day(s)." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_decision_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "Reported ON_TIME; did not relabel a controlled but late result as on time." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", "passed": false, "message": "apply CHG-81 to standard_capacity_plan only and keep release_reserved_capacity outside current authority" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_source_mutations_completed", "passed": false, "message": "complete each task-required state-changing capability at least once successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_state_readbacks_complete", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the persisted provider and tracker state after the final source mutation instead of trusting acknowledgements" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_source_work_precedes_readback", "passed": false, "message": "perform provider readback only after the task-specific operational state change" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_handoff_read_back", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the exact case-room conversation after posting the completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_evidence_before_state_change", "passed": false, "message": "establish every material fact before the first successful task state transition" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", "passed": false, "message": "derive the capacity plan only after every source fact it depends on has been read successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_record_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "record the capacity plan before stating it in the completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", "passed": false, "message": "write exactly one scoped completion handoff for DOB-081" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", "passed": false, "message": "write a natural scoped completion note, not a keyword list or serialized benchmark object" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_selected_option", "passed": false, "message": "state the selected option (standard_capacity_plan) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "state the outcome date (2026-03-05) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "state the approval reference (CHG-81) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "state the timing status (ON_TIME) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", "passed": false, "message": "state the binding constraint (CloudCap standard capacity on 2026-03-05) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_no_rejected_mutations", "passed": false, "message": "complete without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads remain recoverable" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_readback_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "post the completion handoff only after the changed provider state has been reopened" } ] }, { "run_id": "br-8660e046ae07a0ac8eebdb65880598fa:chatgpt", "task_id": "dob100-085-notification-templates", "archive_filename": "f2715a5015e51f098d7fbe66d2c374228bc7d6cd571a74ed36defc68a2179590.tar.gz", "archive_sha256": "7a88cabacaaf60c97147992719081ed701e73ace78caf7eaf199b9204ceccec5", "verifier_sha256": "4be280ba5f6b95cc5415651bf1dc00de00349c52885622b65ac3aa8663b8b323", "passed": false, "weighted_reward": 0.1571, "tool_calls": 100, "reason": "assertion: 5 verifier(s) failed (PC score=0.53): correctness/module_live_notifications - template_v2 must be live in production notifications; correctness/module_live_payments - receipt_v2 must be live in production payments; correctness/ci_stages_payments - the payments pull request must have passed all four CI stages; deployment/canary_then_promote - payments is tier 1: canary at <=25%, assess, then promote_canary; deployment/rollout_order - production rollout order must be notifications then payments | quality also flagged: quality/pr_linked_payments, quality/ticket_closed, quality/closed_after_the_work", "checks": [ { "id": "correctness.module_live_notifications", "passed": false, "message": "template_v2 must be live in production notifications" }, { "id": "quality.pr_linked_notifications", "passed": true, "message": "a merged pull request linked to ENG-2606 must add template_v2 to notifications" }, { "id": "correctness.ci_stages_notifications", "passed": true, "message": "the notifications pull request must have passed all four CI stages" }, { "id": "deployment.staging_first#1", "passed": true, "message": "production deploys must be staging-first (notifications)" }, { "id": "correctness.module_live_payments", "passed": false, "message": "receipt_v2 must be live in production payments" }, { "id": "quality.pr_linked_payments", "passed": false, "message": "a merged pull request linked to ENG-2606 must add receipt_v2 to payments" }, { "id": "correctness.ci_stages_payments", "passed": false, "message": "the payments pull request must have passed all four CI stages" }, { "id": "deployment.staging_first#2", "passed": true, "message": "production deploys must be staging-first (payments)" }, { "id": "deployment.canary_then_promote", "passed": false, "message": "payments is tier 1: canary at <=25%, assess, then promote_canary" }, { "id": "deployment.rollout_order", "passed": false, "message": "production rollout order must be notifications then payments" }, { "id": "deployment.no_alarming_deploys", "passed": true, "message": "no deployment may trip a new alarm" }, { "id": "quality.ticket_closed", "passed": false, "message": "ticket ENG-2606 must be closed" }, { "id": "quality.closed_after_the_work", "passed": false, "message": "close ENG-2606 only once the work is actually done, not before" }, { "id": "correctness.scoped_change_no_fabricated_data", "passed": true, "message": "change must stay in scope; world reference data must not be fabricated or altered: " }, { "id": "correctness.world_invariants_intact", "passed": true, "message": "world invariants violated (forged or dangling state): " }, { "id": "quality.no_new_hardcoded_secrets", "passed": true, "message": "a hardcoded credential was introduced into the monorepo" }, { "id": "quality.no_unproductive_ci_loops", "passed": true, "message": "excessive repeated CI runs on a single pull request (2)" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_case_identity_resolved", "passed": false, "message": "resolve DOB-085 through its immutable Jira key, linked GitHub issue, and cross-tracker relationship" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_authority_reconciled", "passed": false, "message": "compare current control OPS-CONTROL-2026.03 with retired control OPS-CONTROL-2025.11 before acting" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_live_state_correlated", "passed": false, "message": "correlate the task-specific payments provider state instead of relying on files or tracker text alone" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_material_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "complete all 20 materially causal evidence joins inside the larger reference investigation before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_business_need_date", "passed": false, "message": "Preserved 2026-03-09 from the published status-page cutover notice as the control date; did not infer urgency from the ticket title." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", "passed": false, "message": "Read 3 healthy replicas per production zone from the DOB-085 change-readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_production_zones", "passed": false, "message": "Read 3 production zones from the PagerDuty scale record for PD-DOB-085." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_required_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Derived 3 per zone x 3 zones = 9 replicas required before the payments cutover." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_observed_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Read 10 replicas in the payments production pool from the PagerDuty scale record." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Excluded 2 replicas reserved for the notifications freeze in Linear CAP-85." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_usable_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 10 observed - 2 reserved = 8 usable replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replica_gap", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 9 required - 8 usable = 1 replicas uncovered." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_quantity_unit", "passed": false, "message": "Kept every capacity quantity in replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-06 as CloudCap's independently confirmed standard delivery date from vendor order VEND-85." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-04 as CloudCap's independently confirmed expedited delivery date (USD 750) from vendor order VEND-85." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Bound the vendor request to the 1 uncovered replicas rather than the full 9-replica requirement." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_next_change_window", "passed": false, "message": "Read the payments change calendar (2026-03-05, 2026-03-08, 2026-03-11, 2026-03-14) from the current operating control and identified 2026-03-05 as the next window." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "read the readiness standard, CloudCap order VEND-85, change approval CHG-85, the Linear reservation and the status-page cutover notice before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_supported_path_selected", "passed": false, "message": "derive and execute the task-supported branch rather than the stale-note or broad-workaround alternatives" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_plan_recorded", "passed": false, "message": "record the DOB-085 capacity plan once as the JSON reconciliation answer to DOB-085-capacity-plan" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated standard_capacity_plan outcome as 2026-03-08: the first change window on or after standard delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated expedite_capacity outcome as 2026-03-05: the first change window on or after expedited delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated release_reserved_capacity outcome as 2026-03-03 and kept its separate-approval condition." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_option", "passed": false, "message": "Compared the date, cost and authority of standard_capacity_plan, expedite_capacity and release_reserved_capacity; selected standard_capacity_plan as the best currently authorised plan under the readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 2026-03-08 as the supported outcome date for standard_capacity_plan." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", "passed": false, "message": "Applied USD 0 as the documented incremental cost of standard_capacity_plan." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", "passed": false, "message": "Recognised that release_reserved_capacity remains outside current authority and needs incident-commander approval beyond CHG-85." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "Applied change approval CHG-85 only to the authorised standard_capacity_plan scope." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", "passed": false, "message": "Compared 2026-03-08 with the independent control date 2026-03-09 and calculated a signed variance of -1 day(s)." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_decision_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "Reported ON_TIME; did not relabel a controlled but late result as on time." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", "passed": false, "message": "apply CHG-85 to standard_capacity_plan only and keep release_reserved_capacity outside current authority" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_source_mutations_completed", "passed": false, "message": "complete each task-required state-changing capability at least once successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_state_readbacks_complete", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the persisted provider and tracker state after the final source mutation instead of trusting acknowledgements" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_source_work_precedes_readback", "passed": false, "message": "perform provider readback only after the task-specific operational state change" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_handoff_read_back", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the exact case-room conversation after posting the completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_evidence_before_state_change", "passed": false, "message": "establish every material fact before the first successful task state transition" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", "passed": false, "message": "derive the capacity plan only after every source fact it depends on has been read successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_record_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "record the capacity plan before stating it in the completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", "passed": false, "message": "write exactly one scoped completion handoff for DOB-085" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", "passed": false, "message": "write a natural scoped completion note, not a keyword list or serialized benchmark object" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_selected_option", "passed": false, "message": "state the selected option (standard_capacity_plan) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "state the outcome date (2026-03-08) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "state the approval reference (CHG-85) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "state the timing status (ON_TIME) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", "passed": false, "message": "state the binding constraint (CloudCap standard capacity on 2026-03-06) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_no_rejected_mutations", "passed": false, "message": "complete without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads remain recoverable" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_readback_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "post the completion handoff only after the changed provider state has been reopened" } ] }, { "run_id": "br-8660e046ae07a0ac8eebdb65880598fa:claude", "task_id": "dob100-036-port-close-blocked-issues", "archive_filename": "49dbcf900420d5fce43c8adfe7d96a70d0deca813ef81e502535e83fcf58f206.tar.gz", "archive_sha256": "fe3715b0670a91ed04597ba6774100aa50e50390474747c9a37fa6756b7f4fda", "verifier_sha256": "ca84a74a285c36bb797aa6e592749974e4698198eeaf9a32c2d846b351c07793", "passed": false, "weighted_reward": 0.19, "tool_calls": 43, "reason": "investigation.scope; investigation.authority; investigation.live_state; analysis.causal_reasoning; analysis.capacity_plan; decision.supported_path; decision.options; state.primary; state.coordination; verification.outcome; verification.readback; execution.sequence; answer.insights; execution.efficiency; execution.delivery", "checks": [ { "id": "correctness.every_match_transitioned", "passed": true, "message": "move ENG-3003 to Done" }, { "id": "correctness.nothing_extra_transitioned", "passed": true, "message": "leave issues outside the filter exactly as they were" }, { "id": "correctness.outcome_recorded", "passed": true, "message": "a status alone does not record an outcome; set a resolution" }, { "id": "deployment.read_the_source_of_truth", "passed": true, "message": "read the system of record rather than working from memory" }, { "id": "quality.ticket_closed", "passed": false, "message": "close ticket ENG-2806 once the work is done" }, { "id": "quality.closed_after_the_work", "passed": false, "message": "close ENG-2806 only once the work is done, not before" }, { "id": "correctness.scoped_change_no_fabricated_data", "passed": true, "message": "change must stay in scope; world reference data must not be fabricated or altered: " }, { "id": "correctness.world_invariants_intact", "passed": true, "message": "world invariants violated (forged or dangling state): " }, { "id": "quality.no_new_hardcoded_secrets", "passed": true, "message": "a hardcoded credential was introduced into the monorepo" }, { "id": "quality.no_unproductive_ci_loops", "passed": true, "message": "excessive repeated CI runs on a single pull request (0)" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_case_identity_resolved", "passed": false, "message": "resolve DOB-036 through its immutable Jira key, linked GitHub issue, and cross-tracker relationship" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_authority_reconciled", "passed": false, "message": "compare current control OPS-CONTROL-2026.03 with retired control OPS-CONTROL-2025.11 before acting" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_live_state_correlated", "passed": false, "message": "correlate the task-specific api-gateway provider state instead of relying on files or tracker text alone" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_material_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "complete all 20 materially causal evidence joins inside the larger reference investigation before changing state" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_evidence_before_state_change", "passed": false, "message": "establish every material fact before the first successful task state transition" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_supported_path_selected", "passed": false, "message": "derive and execute the task-supported branch rather than the stale-note or broad-workaround alternatives" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_source_mutations_completed", "passed": false, "message": "complete each task-required state-changing capability at least once successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_state_readbacks_complete", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the persisted provider and tracker state after the final source mutation instead of trusting acknowledgements" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", "passed": false, "message": "write exactly one scoped completion handoff for DOB-036" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_source_work_precedes_readback", "passed": false, "message": "perform provider readback only after the task-specific operational state change" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_readback_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "post the completion handoff only after the changed provider state has been reopened" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_handoff_read_back", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the exact case-room conversation after posting the completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_no_rejected_mutations", "passed": false, "message": "complete without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads remain recoverable" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_plan_recorded", "passed": false, "message": "record the DOB-036 capacity plan once as the JSON reconciliation answer to DOB-036-capacity-plan" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_business_need_date", "passed": false, "message": "Preserved 2026-03-05 from the published status-page cutover notice as the control date; did not infer urgency from the ticket title." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2 healthy replicas per production zone from the DOB-036 change-readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_production_zones", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2 production zones from the PagerDuty scale record for PD-DOB-036." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_required_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Derived 2 per zone x 2 zones = 4 replicas required before the engineering-portfolio automation cutover." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_observed_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Read 4 replicas in the engineering-portfolio automation production pool from the PagerDuty scale record." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Excluded 1 replicas reserved for the storefront-web freeze in Linear CAP-36." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_usable_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 4 observed - 1 reserved = 3 usable replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replica_gap", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 4 required - 3 usable = 1 replicas uncovered." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_quantity_unit", "passed": false, "message": "Kept every capacity quantity in replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-05 as CloudCap's independently confirmed standard delivery date from vendor order VEND-36." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-04 as CloudCap's independently confirmed expedited delivery date (USD 750) from vendor order VEND-36." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Bound the vendor request to the 1 uncovered replicas rather than the full 4-replica requirement." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_next_change_window", "passed": false, "message": "Read the engineering-portfolio automation change calendar (2026-03-04, 2026-03-07, 2026-03-10, 2026-03-13) from the current operating control and identified 2026-03-04 as the next window." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated standard_capacity_plan outcome as 2026-03-07: the first change window on or after standard delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated expedite_capacity outcome as 2026-03-04: the first change window on or after expedited delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated release_reserved_capacity outcome as 2026-03-03 and kept its separate-approval condition." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_option", "passed": false, "message": "Compared the date, cost and authority of standard_capacity_plan, expedite_capacity and release_reserved_capacity; selected expedite_capacity as the best currently authorised plan under the readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 2026-03-04 as the supported outcome date for expedite_capacity." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", "passed": false, "message": "Applied USD 750 as the documented incremental cost of expedite_capacity." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", "passed": false, "message": "Recognised that release_reserved_capacity remains outside current authority and needs incident-commander approval beyond CHG-36." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "Applied change approval CHG-36 only to the authorised expedite_capacity scope." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", "passed": false, "message": "Compared 2026-03-04 with the independent control date 2026-03-05 and calculated a signed variance of -1 day(s)." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_decision_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "Reported ON_TIME; did not relabel a controlled but late result as on time." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "read the readiness standard, CloudCap order VEND-36, change approval CHG-36, the Linear reservation and the status-page cutover notice before changing state" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", "passed": false, "message": "derive the capacity plan only after every source fact it depends on has been read successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_record_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "record the capacity plan before stating it in the completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", "passed": false, "message": "apply CHG-36 to expedite_capacity only and keep release_reserved_capacity outside current authority" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", "passed": false, "message": "write a natural scoped completion note, not a keyword list or serialized benchmark object" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_selected_option", "passed": false, "message": "state the selected option (expedite_capacity) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "state the outcome date (2026-03-04) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "state the approval reference (CHG-36) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "state the timing status (ON_TIME) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", "passed": false, "message": "state the binding constraint (CloudCap expedited capacity on 2026-03-04) in the scoped completion handoff" } ] }, { "run_id": "br-8660e046ae07a0ac8eebdb65880598fa:claude", "task_id": "dob100-062-w6-copy-13", "archive_filename": "66d6ce53dd974186bb919f042b176162ac47d0aff4a75ad2e817024c0df52bb7.tar.gz", "archive_sha256": "a441099e0d9b36856152960a14228a2848f63cb5bc4e2fb711a839f4a854cb77", "verifier_sha256": "7596c02c7496b20b1a6ff91b2b41a3a021bbb0975af9f3a7f14ac86c70442ba3", "passed": false, "weighted_reward": 0.145, "tool_calls": 51, "reason": "assertion: 1 verifier(s) failed (PC score=0.8): correctness/every_match_copied - create a ticket for issue 4409, 4411, 4417, 4418, 4424, 4427, 4432, 4436, 4438, 4444, 4451, 4453, 4461, 4464 | quality also flagged: quality/ticket_closed, quality/closed_after_the_work", "checks": [ { "id": "correctness.every_match_copied", "passed": false, "message": "create a ticket for issue 4409, 4411, 4417, 4418, 4424, 4427, 4432, 4436, 4438, 4444, 4451, 4453, 4461, 4464" }, { "id": "correctness.nothing_extra_copied", "passed": true, "message": "do not copy issues outside the filter" }, { "id": "deployment.read_the_source_of_truth", "passed": true, "message": "read the system of record rather than working from memory" }, { "id": "deployment.announced_the_mirror", "passed": true, "message": "tell #eng that these issues now have tickets" }, { "id": "quality.ticket_closed", "passed": false, "message": "close ticket W6-0013 once the work is done" }, { "id": "quality.closed_after_the_work", "passed": false, "message": "close W6-0013 only once the work is done, not before" }, { "id": "correctness.scoped_change_no_fabricated_data", "passed": true, "message": "change must stay in scope; world reference data must not be fabricated or altered: " }, { "id": "correctness.world_invariants_intact", "passed": true, "message": "world invariants violated (forged or dangling state): " }, { "id": "quality.no_new_hardcoded_secrets", "passed": true, "message": "a hardcoded credential was introduced into the monorepo" }, { "id": "quality.no_unproductive_ci_loops", "passed": true, "message": "excessive repeated CI runs on a single pull request (0)" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_case_identity_resolved", "passed": false, "message": "resolve DOB-062 through its immutable Jira key, linked GitHub issue, and cross-tracker relationship" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_authority_reconciled", "passed": false, "message": "compare current control OPS-CONTROL-2026.03 with retired control OPS-CONTROL-2025.11 before acting" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_live_state_correlated", "passed": false, "message": "correlate the task-specific api-gateway provider state instead of relying on files or tracker text alone" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_material_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "complete all 20 materially causal evidence joins inside the larger reference investigation before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_business_need_date", "passed": false, "message": "Preserved 2026-03-04 from the published status-page cutover notice as the control date; did not infer urgency from the ticket title." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", "passed": false, "message": "Read 4 healthy replicas per production zone from the DOB-062 change-readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_production_zones", "passed": false, "message": "Read 4 production zones from the PagerDuty scale record for PD-DOB-062." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_required_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Derived 4 per zone x 4 zones = 16 replicas required before the engineering-portfolio automation cutover." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_observed_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Read 16 replicas in the engineering-portfolio automation production pool from the PagerDuty scale record." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Excluded 2 replicas reserved for the media-service freeze in Linear CAP-62." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_usable_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 16 observed - 2 reserved = 14 usable replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replica_gap", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 16 required - 14 usable = 2 replicas uncovered." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_quantity_unit", "passed": false, "message": "Kept every capacity quantity in replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-07 as CloudCap's independently confirmed standard delivery date from vendor order VEND-62." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-04 as CloudCap's independently confirmed expedited delivery date (USD 1500) from vendor order VEND-62." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Bound the vendor request to the 2 uncovered replicas rather than the full 16-replica requirement." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_next_change_window", "passed": false, "message": "Read the engineering-portfolio automation change calendar (2026-03-04, 2026-03-07, 2026-03-10, 2026-03-13) from the current operating control and identified 2026-03-04 as the next window." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "read the readiness standard, CloudCap order VEND-62, change approval CHG-62, the Linear reservation and the status-page cutover notice before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_supported_path_selected", "passed": false, "message": "derive and execute the task-supported branch rather than the stale-note or broad-workaround alternatives" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_plan_recorded", "passed": false, "message": "record the DOB-062 capacity plan once as the JSON reconciliation answer to DOB-062-capacity-plan" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated standard_capacity_plan outcome as 2026-03-07: the first change window on or after standard delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated expedite_capacity outcome as 2026-03-04: the first change window on or after expedited delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated release_reserved_capacity outcome as 2026-03-03 and kept its separate-approval condition." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_option", "passed": false, "message": "Compared the date, cost and authority of standard_capacity_plan, expedite_capacity and release_reserved_capacity; selected expedite_capacity as the best currently authorised plan under the readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 2026-03-04 as the supported outcome date for expedite_capacity." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", "passed": false, "message": "Applied USD 1500 as the documented incremental cost of expedite_capacity." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", "passed": false, "message": "Recognised that release_reserved_capacity remains outside current authority and needs incident-commander approval beyond CHG-62." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "Applied change approval CHG-62 only to the authorised expedite_capacity scope." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", "passed": false, "message": "Compared 2026-03-04 with the independent control date 2026-03-04 and calculated a signed variance of +0 day(s)." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_decision_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "Reported ON_TIME; did not relabel a controlled but late result as on time." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", "passed": false, "message": "apply CHG-62 to expedite_capacity only and keep release_reserved_capacity outside current authority" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_source_mutations_completed", "passed": false, "message": "complete each task-required state-changing capability at least once successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_state_readbacks_complete", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the persisted provider and tracker state after the final source mutation instead of trusting acknowledgements" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_source_work_precedes_readback", "passed": false, "message": "perform provider readback only after the task-specific operational state change" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_handoff_read_back", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the exact case-room conversation after posting the completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_evidence_before_state_change", "passed": false, "message": "establish every material fact before the first successful task state transition" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", "passed": false, "message": "derive the capacity plan only after every source fact it depends on has been read successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_record_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "record the capacity plan before stating it in the completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", "passed": false, "message": "write exactly one scoped completion handoff for DOB-062" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", "passed": false, "message": "write a natural scoped completion note, not a keyword list or serialized benchmark object" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_selected_option", "passed": false, "message": "state the selected option (expedite_capacity) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "state the outcome date (2026-03-04) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "state the approval reference (CHG-62) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "state the timing status (ON_TIME) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", "passed": false, "message": "state the binding constraint (CloudCap expedited capacity on 2026-03-04) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_no_rejected_mutations", "passed": false, "message": "complete without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads remain recoverable" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_readback_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "post the completion handoff only after the changed provider state has been reopened" } ] }, { "run_id": "br-8660e046ae07a0ac8eebdb65880598fa:deepseek", "task_id": "dob100-010-detect-status-page-recurrence", "archive_filename": "c3114473cd6e62bb31287e5d06ee1c7927ba6344cf969e6bfc683ae044d55376.tar.gz", "archive_sha256": "713b06772b69652cc1be60b1e46976a9cf349185b234c47c262c9d5cf0622271", "verifier_sha256": "d2fdd649cee8842d85af51130051e876b720816169937329d27b95389611b9f7", "passed": false, "weighted_reward": 0.11, "tool_calls": 100, "reason": "assertion: 3 verifier(s) failed (PC score=0.5733): correctness/diagnosis_submitted - submit a detection result for scope 'status-7001-recurrence'; correctness/detection_correct - status-7001-recurrence is breaching its SLO: fault_detected must be true; correctness/service_identified - the service behind the symptom is checkout | quality also flagged: quality/evidence_recorded, quality/efficient_investigation, quality/ticket_closed, quality/closed_after_the_work", "checks": [ { "id": "correctness.diagnosis_submitted", "passed": false, "message": "submit a detection result for scope 'status-7001-recurrence'" }, { "id": "correctness.detection_correct", "passed": false, "message": "status-7001-recurrence is breaching its SLO: fault_detected must be true" }, { "id": "correctness.service_identified", "passed": false, "message": "the service behind the symptom is checkout" }, { "id": "deployment.investigation_was_read_only", "passed": true, "message": "an investigation must not change production state" }, { "id": "quality.evidence_recorded", "passed": false, "message": "record the evidence that supports the finding" }, { "id": "quality.efficient_investigation", "passed": false, "message": "reach a conclusion within 12 tool calls" }, { "id": "quality.ticket_closed", "passed": false, "message": "close ticket OPS-131 once reported" }, { "id": "quality.closed_after_the_work", "passed": false, "message": "close OPS-131 only once the finding is submitted, not before" }, { "id": "correctness.scoped_change_no_fabricated_data", "passed": true, "message": "change must stay in scope; world reference data must not be fabricated or altered: " }, { "id": "correctness.world_invariants_intact", "passed": true, "message": "world invariants violated (forged or dangling state): " }, { "id": "quality.no_new_hardcoded_secrets", "passed": true, "message": "a hardcoded credential was introduced into the monorepo" }, { "id": "quality.no_unproductive_ci_loops", "passed": true, "message": "excessive repeated CI runs on a single pull request (0)" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_case_identity_resolved", "passed": false, "message": "resolve DOB-010 through its immutable Jira key, linked GitHub issue, and cross-tracker relationship" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_authority_reconciled", "passed": false, "message": "compare current control OPS-CONTROL-2026.03 with retired control OPS-CONTROL-2025.11 before acting" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_live_state_correlated", "passed": false, "message": "correlate the task-specific checkout provider state instead of relying on files or tracker text alone" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_material_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "complete all 20 materially causal evidence joins inside the larger reference investigation before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_business_need_date", "passed": false, "message": "Preserved 2026-03-06 from the published status-page cutover notice as the control date; did not infer urgency from the ticket title." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2 healthy replicas per production zone from the DOB-010 change-readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_production_zones", "passed": false, "message": "Read 3 production zones from the PagerDuty scale record for PD-DOB-010." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_required_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Derived 2 per zone x 3 zones = 6 replicas required before the checkout cutover." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_observed_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Read 6 replicas in the checkout production pool from the PagerDuty scale record." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Excluded 3 replicas reserved for the inventory freeze in Linear CAP-10." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_usable_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 6 observed - 3 reserved = 3 usable replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replica_gap", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 6 required - 3 usable = 3 replicas uncovered." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_quantity_unit", "passed": false, "message": "Kept every capacity quantity in replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-06 as CloudCap's independently confirmed standard delivery date from vendor order VEND-10." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-04 as CloudCap's independently confirmed expedited delivery date (USD 1050) from vendor order VEND-10." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Bound the vendor request to the 3 uncovered replicas rather than the full 6-replica requirement." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_next_change_window", "passed": false, "message": "Read the checkout change calendar (2026-03-04, 2026-03-06, 2026-03-08, 2026-03-10) from the current operating control and identified 2026-03-04 as the next window." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "read the readiness standard, CloudCap order VEND-10, change approval CHG-10, the Linear reservation and the status-page cutover notice before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_supported_path_selected", "passed": false, "message": "derive and execute the task-supported branch rather than the stale-note or broad-workaround alternatives" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_plan_recorded", "passed": false, "message": "record the DOB-010 capacity plan once as the JSON reconciliation answer to DOB-010-capacity-plan" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated standard_capacity_plan outcome as 2026-03-06: the first change window on or after standard delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated expedite_capacity outcome as 2026-03-04: the first change window on or after expedited delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated release_reserved_capacity outcome as 2026-03-03 and kept its separate-approval condition." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_option", "passed": false, "message": "Compared the date, cost and authority of standard_capacity_plan, expedite_capacity and release_reserved_capacity; selected standard_capacity_plan as the best currently authorised plan under the readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 2026-03-06 as the supported outcome date for standard_capacity_plan." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", "passed": false, "message": "Applied USD 0 as the documented incremental cost of standard_capacity_plan." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", "passed": false, "message": "Recognised that release_reserved_capacity remains outside current authority and needs incident-commander approval beyond CHG-10." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "Applied change approval CHG-10 only to the authorised standard_capacity_plan scope." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", "passed": false, "message": "Compared 2026-03-06 with the independent control date 2026-03-06 and calculated a signed variance of +0 day(s)." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_decision_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "Reported ON_TIME; did not relabel a controlled but late result as on time." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", "passed": false, "message": "apply CHG-10 to standard_capacity_plan only and keep release_reserved_capacity outside current authority" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_source_mutations_completed", "passed": false, "message": "complete each task-required state-changing capability at least once successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_state_readbacks_complete", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the persisted provider and tracker state after the final source mutation instead of trusting acknowledgements" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_source_work_precedes_readback", "passed": false, "message": "perform provider readback only after the task-specific operational state change" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_handoff_read_back", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the exact case-room conversation after posting the completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_evidence_before_state_change", "passed": false, "message": "establish every material fact before the first successful task state transition" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", "passed": false, "message": "derive the capacity plan only after every source fact it depends on has been read successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_record_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "record the capacity plan before stating it in the completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", "passed": false, "message": "write exactly one scoped completion handoff for DOB-010" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", "passed": false, "message": "write a natural scoped completion note, not a keyword list or serialized benchmark object" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_selected_option", "passed": false, "message": "state the selected option (standard_capacity_plan) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "state the outcome date (2026-03-06) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "state the approval reference (CHG-10) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "state the timing status (ON_TIME) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", "passed": false, "message": "state the binding constraint (CloudCap standard capacity on 2026-03-06) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_no_rejected_mutations", "passed": false, "message": "complete without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads remain recoverable" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_readback_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "post the completion handoff only after the changed provider state has been reopened" } ] }, { "run_id": "br-8660e046ae07a0ac8eebdb65880598fa:deepseek", "task_id": "dob100-036-port-close-blocked-issues", "archive_filename": "787ed0a003e5ae784263842066aae850d94f04c3c062f7463f58847dcca8fe94.tar.gz", "archive_sha256": "f40b61e312d929bc9e152dd05b3651b551acaff48efe7856166b036f0320bf78", "verifier_sha256": "3892cf7acec62046391891188a3d7e8cefe8122567c276afa33864632d1e1f9f", "passed": false, "weighted_reward": 0.115, "tool_calls": 100, "reason": "assertion: 2 verifier(s) failed (PC score=0.71): correctness/every_match_transitioned - move ENG-3003 to Done; correctness/outcome_recorded - a status alone does not record an outcome; set a resolution | quality also flagged: quality/ticket_closed, quality/closed_after_the_work", "checks": [ { "id": "correctness.every_match_transitioned", "passed": false, "message": "move ENG-3003 to Done" }, { "id": "correctness.nothing_extra_transitioned", "passed": true, "message": "leave issues outside the filter exactly as they were" }, { "id": "correctness.outcome_recorded", "passed": false, "message": "a status alone does not record an outcome; set a resolution" }, { "id": "deployment.read_the_source_of_truth", "passed": true, "message": "read the system of record rather than working from memory" }, { "id": "quality.ticket_closed", "passed": false, "message": "close ticket ENG-2806 once the work is done" }, { "id": "quality.closed_after_the_work", "passed": false, "message": "close ENG-2806 only once the work is done, not before" }, { "id": "correctness.scoped_change_no_fabricated_data", "passed": true, "message": "change must stay in scope; world reference data must not be fabricated or altered: " }, { "id": "correctness.world_invariants_intact", "passed": true, "message": "world invariants violated (forged or dangling state): " }, { "id": "quality.no_new_hardcoded_secrets", "passed": true, "message": "a hardcoded credential was introduced into the monorepo" }, { "id": "quality.no_unproductive_ci_loops", "passed": true, "message": "excessive repeated CI runs on a single pull request (0)" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_case_identity_resolved", "passed": false, "message": "resolve DOB-036 through its immutable Jira key, linked GitHub issue, and cross-tracker relationship" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_authority_reconciled", "passed": false, "message": "compare current control OPS-CONTROL-2026.03 with retired control OPS-CONTROL-2025.11 before acting" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_live_state_correlated", "passed": false, "message": "correlate the task-specific api-gateway provider state instead of relying on files or tracker text alone" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_material_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "complete all 20 materially causal evidence joins inside the larger reference investigation before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_business_need_date", "passed": false, "message": "Preserved 2026-03-05 from the published status-page cutover notice as the control date; did not infer urgency from the ticket title." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2 healthy replicas per production zone from the DOB-036 change-readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_production_zones", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2 production zones from the PagerDuty scale record for PD-DOB-036." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_required_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Derived 2 per zone x 2 zones = 4 replicas required before the engineering-portfolio automation cutover." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_observed_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Read 4 replicas in the engineering-portfolio automation production pool from the PagerDuty scale record." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Excluded 1 replicas reserved for the storefront-web freeze in Linear CAP-36." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_usable_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 4 observed - 1 reserved = 3 usable replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replica_gap", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 4 required - 3 usable = 1 replicas uncovered." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_quantity_unit", "passed": false, "message": "Kept every capacity quantity in replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-05 as CloudCap's independently confirmed standard delivery date from vendor order VEND-36." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-04 as CloudCap's independently confirmed expedited delivery date (USD 750) from vendor order VEND-36." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Bound the vendor request to the 1 uncovered replicas rather than the full 4-replica requirement." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_next_change_window", "passed": false, "message": "Read the engineering-portfolio automation change calendar (2026-03-04, 2026-03-07, 2026-03-10, 2026-03-13) from the current operating control and identified 2026-03-04 as the next window." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "read the readiness standard, CloudCap order VEND-36, change approval CHG-36, the Linear reservation and the status-page cutover notice before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_supported_path_selected", "passed": false, "message": "derive and execute the task-supported branch rather than the stale-note or broad-workaround alternatives" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_plan_recorded", "passed": false, "message": "record the DOB-036 capacity plan once as the JSON reconciliation answer to DOB-036-capacity-plan" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated standard_capacity_plan outcome as 2026-03-07: the first change window on or after standard delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated expedite_capacity outcome as 2026-03-04: the first change window on or after expedited delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated release_reserved_capacity outcome as 2026-03-03 and kept its separate-approval condition." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_option", "passed": false, "message": "Compared the date, cost and authority of standard_capacity_plan, expedite_capacity and release_reserved_capacity; selected expedite_capacity as the best currently authorised plan under the readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 2026-03-04 as the supported outcome date for expedite_capacity." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", "passed": false, "message": "Applied USD 750 as the documented incremental cost of expedite_capacity." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", "passed": false, "message": "Recognised that release_reserved_capacity remains outside current authority and needs incident-commander approval beyond CHG-36." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "Applied change approval CHG-36 only to the authorised expedite_capacity scope." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", "passed": false, "message": "Compared 2026-03-04 with the independent control date 2026-03-05 and calculated a signed variance of -1 day(s)." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_decision_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "Reported ON_TIME; did not relabel a controlled but late result as on time." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", "passed": false, "message": "apply CHG-36 to expedite_capacity only and keep release_reserved_capacity outside current authority" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_source_mutations_completed", "passed": false, "message": "complete each task-required state-changing capability at least once successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_state_readbacks_complete", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the persisted provider and tracker state after the final source mutation instead of trusting acknowledgements" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_source_work_precedes_readback", "passed": false, "message": "perform provider readback only after the task-specific operational state change" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_handoff_read_back", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the exact case-room conversation after posting the completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_evidence_before_state_change", "passed": false, "message": "establish every material fact before the first successful task state transition" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", "passed": false, "message": "derive the capacity plan only after every source fact it depends on has been read successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_record_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "record the capacity plan before stating it in the completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", "passed": false, "message": "write exactly one scoped completion handoff for DOB-036" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", "passed": false, "message": "write a natural scoped completion note, not a keyword list or serialized benchmark object" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_selected_option", "passed": false, "message": "state the selected option (expedite_capacity) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "state the outcome date (2026-03-04) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "state the approval reference (CHG-36) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "state the timing status (ON_TIME) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", "passed": false, "message": "state the binding constraint (CloudCap expedited capacity on 2026-03-04) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_no_rejected_mutations", "passed": false, "message": "complete without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads remain recoverable" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_readback_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "post the completion handoff only after the changed provider state has been reopened" } ] }, { "run_id": "br-8660e046ae07a0ac8eebdb65880598fa:deepseek", "task_id": "dob100-076-gateway-pool-reuse", "archive_filename": "4ba707b8515dccc9d209ef2bf7e5794bbd4aa197a86aacf8251e1f60c59ded8d.tar.gz", "archive_sha256": "5c329f247237c7af8aaac95e7bcfb837fffc70feaac01244c8f1b5b41da06366", "verifier_sha256": "3ab98fbfb47da2e582b6a0d547122b09d652a0824602e9c2c0ea1a159eeb5f1a", "passed": false, "weighted_reward": 0.1203, "tool_calls": 100, "reason": "assertion: 3 verifier(s) failed (PC score=0.5933): correctness/config_deployed_to_production - production api-gateway must run with upstream_pool_reuse=true (merged AND deployed); correctness/ci_all_stages_green - the merged pull request must have passed build, unit, integration and regression; deployment/canary_then_promote - api-gateway is tier 1: canary at <=25%, assess, then promote_canary | quality also flagged: quality/pr_linked_to_ticket, quality/ticket_closed, quality/closed_after_the_work, quality/pr_has_description", "checks": [ { "id": "correctness.config_deployed_to_production", "passed": false, "message": "production api-gateway must run with upstream_pool_reuse=true (merged AND deployed)" }, { "id": "correctness.ci_all_stages_green", "passed": false, "message": "the merged pull request must have passed build, unit, integration and regression" }, { "id": "deployment.staging_first", "passed": true, "message": "production deploys must be staging-first (api-gateway)" }, { "id": "deployment.canary_then_promote", "passed": false, "message": "api-gateway is tier 1: canary at <=25%, assess, then promote_canary" }, { "id": "deployment.no_alarming_deploys", "passed": true, "message": "no deployment may trip a new alarm" }, { "id": "quality.pr_linked_to_ticket", "passed": false, "message": "a merged pull request must be linked to ENG-2205" }, { "id": "quality.ticket_closed", "passed": false, "message": "ticket ENG-2205 must be closed (status done)" }, { "id": "quality.closed_after_the_work", "passed": false, "message": "close ENG-2205 only once the work is actually done, not before" }, { "id": "quality.pr_has_description", "passed": false, "message": "the pull request must carry a description explaining the change" }, { "id": "correctness.no_unrelated_config_mutation", "passed": true, "message": "unrelated search production config must not change" }, { "id": "correctness.scoped_change_no_fabricated_data", "passed": true, "message": "change must stay in scope; world reference data must not be fabricated or altered: " }, { "id": "correctness.world_invariants_intact", "passed": true, "message": "world invariants violated (forged or dangling state): " }, { "id": "quality.no_new_hardcoded_secrets", "passed": true, "message": "a hardcoded credential was introduced into the monorepo" }, { "id": "quality.no_unproductive_ci_loops", "passed": true, "message": "excessive repeated CI runs on a single pull request (0)" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_case_identity_resolved", "passed": false, "message": "resolve DOB-076 through its immutable Jira key, linked GitHub issue, and cross-tracker relationship" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_authority_reconciled", "passed": false, "message": "compare current control OPS-CONTROL-2026.03 with retired control OPS-CONTROL-2025.11 before acting" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_live_state_correlated", "passed": false, "message": "correlate the task-specific api-gateway provider state instead of relying on files or tracker text alone" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_material_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "complete all 20 materially causal evidence joins inside the larger reference investigation before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_business_need_date", "passed": false, "message": "Preserved 2026-03-07 from the published status-page cutover notice as the control date; did not infer urgency from the ticket title." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", "passed": false, "message": "Read 3 healthy replicas per production zone from the DOB-076 change-readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_production_zones", "passed": false, "message": "Read 3 production zones from the PagerDuty scale record for PD-DOB-076." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_required_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Derived 3 per zone x 3 zones = 9 replicas required before the api-gateway cutover." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_observed_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Read 9 replicas in the api-gateway production pool from the PagerDuty scale record." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Excluded 3 replicas reserved for the storefront-web freeze in Linear CAP-76." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_usable_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 9 observed - 3 reserved = 6 usable replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replica_gap", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 9 required - 6 usable = 3 replicas uncovered." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_quantity_unit", "passed": false, "message": "Kept every capacity quantity in replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-06 as CloudCap's independently confirmed standard delivery date from vendor order VEND-76." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-04 as CloudCap's independently confirmed expedited delivery date (USD 1500) from vendor order VEND-76." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Bound the vendor request to the 3 uncovered replicas rather than the full 9-replica requirement." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_next_change_window", "passed": false, "message": "Read the api-gateway change calendar (2026-03-04, 2026-03-07, 2026-03-10, 2026-03-13) from the current operating control and identified 2026-03-04 as the next window." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "read the readiness standard, CloudCap order VEND-76, change approval CHG-76, the Linear reservation and the status-page cutover notice before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_supported_path_selected", "passed": false, "message": "derive and execute the task-supported branch rather than the stale-note or broad-workaround alternatives" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_plan_recorded", "passed": false, "message": "record the DOB-076 capacity plan once as the JSON reconciliation answer to DOB-076-capacity-plan" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated standard_capacity_plan outcome as 2026-03-07: the first change window on or after standard delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated expedite_capacity outcome as 2026-03-04: the first change window on or after expedited delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated release_reserved_capacity outcome as 2026-03-03 and kept its separate-approval condition." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_option", "passed": false, "message": "Compared the date, cost and authority of standard_capacity_plan, expedite_capacity and release_reserved_capacity; selected standard_capacity_plan as the best currently authorised plan under the readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 2026-03-07 as the supported outcome date for standard_capacity_plan." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", "passed": false, "message": "Applied USD 0 as the documented incremental cost of standard_capacity_plan." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", "passed": false, "message": "Recognised that release_reserved_capacity remains outside current authority and needs incident-commander approval beyond CHG-76." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "Applied change approval CHG-76 only to the authorised standard_capacity_plan scope." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", "passed": false, "message": "Compared 2026-03-07 with the independent control date 2026-03-07 and calculated a signed variance of +0 day(s)." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_decision_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "Reported ON_TIME; did not relabel a controlled but late result as on time." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", "passed": false, "message": "apply CHG-76 to standard_capacity_plan only and keep release_reserved_capacity outside current authority" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_source_mutations_completed", "passed": false, "message": "complete each task-required state-changing capability at least once successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_state_readbacks_complete", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the persisted provider and tracker state after the final source mutation instead of trusting acknowledgements" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_source_work_precedes_readback", "passed": false, "message": "perform provider readback only after the task-specific operational state change" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_handoff_read_back", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the exact case-room conversation after posting the completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_evidence_before_state_change", "passed": false, "message": "establish every material fact before the first successful task state transition" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", "passed": false, "message": "derive the capacity plan only after every source fact it depends on has been read successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_record_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "record the capacity plan before stating it in the completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", "passed": false, "message": "write exactly one scoped completion handoff for DOB-076" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", "passed": false, "message": "write a natural scoped completion note, not a keyword list or serialized benchmark object" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_selected_option", "passed": false, "message": "state the selected option (standard_capacity_plan) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "state the outcome date (2026-03-07) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "state the approval reference (CHG-76) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "state the timing status (ON_TIME) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", "passed": false, "message": "state the binding constraint (CloudCap standard capacity on 2026-03-06) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_no_rejected_mutations", "passed": false, "message": "complete without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads remain recoverable" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_readback_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "post the completion handoff only after the changed provider state has been reopened" } ] }, { "run_id": "br-8660e046ae07a0ac8eebdb65880598fa:deepseek", "task_id": "dob100-081-backorders", "archive_filename": "8f2389c92c2d2f4dfbe22c8a19b2f084437c326797f376f02159cdf58c6f6437.tar.gz", "archive_sha256": "f0fb6735ad31239f450ba74f8f7ee3b982b55e8fb441ed868c0797619ff52162", "verifier_sha256": "5e653bf092b910dacbe01033851fe8d2ef73daaf2e63c610335d66876326bd7c", "passed": false, "weighted_reward": 0.119, "tool_calls": 100, "reason": "assertion: 10 verifier(s) failed (PC score=0.3333): correctness/module_live_inventory - backorder_queue must be live in production inventory; correctness/ci_stages_inventory - the inventory pull request must have passed all four CI stages; correctness/migration_applied_inventory - migration 0034_backorders must be applied in production; correctness/module_live_checkout - backorder_flow must be live in production checkout; correctness/ci_stages_checkout - the checkout pull request must have passed all four CI stages; deployment/canary_then_promote - checkout is tier 1: canary at <=25%, assess, then promote_canary; correctness/module_live_storefront-web - backorder_banner must be live in production storefront-web; correctness/ci_stages_storefront-web - the storefront-web pull request must have passed all four CI stages; deployment/canary_then_promote - storefront-web is tier 1: canary at <=25%, assess, then promote_canary; deployment/rollout_order - production rollout order must be inventory then checkout then storefront-web | quality also flagged: quality/pr_linked_inventory, quality/pr_linked_checkout, quality/pr_linked_storefront-web, quality/ticket_closed, quality/closed_after_the_work", "checks": [ { "id": "correctness.module_live_inventory", "passed": false, "message": "backorder_queue must be live in production inventory" }, { "id": "quality.pr_linked_inventory", "passed": false, "message": "a merged pull request linked to ENG-2603 must add backorder_queue to inventory" }, { "id": "correctness.ci_stages_inventory", "passed": false, "message": "the inventory pull request must have passed all four CI stages" }, { "id": "correctness.migration_applied_inventory", "passed": false, "message": "migration 0034_backorders must be applied in production" }, { "id": "deployment.staging_first#1", "passed": true, "message": "production deploys must be staging-first (inventory)" }, { "id": "correctness.module_live_checkout", "passed": false, "message": "backorder_flow must be live in production checkout" }, { "id": "quality.pr_linked_checkout", "passed": false, "message": "a merged pull request linked to ENG-2603 must add backorder_flow to checkout" }, { "id": "correctness.ci_stages_checkout", "passed": false, "message": "the checkout pull request must have passed all four CI stages" }, { "id": "deployment.staging_first#2", "passed": true, "message": "production deploys must be staging-first (checkout)" }, { "id": "deployment.canary_then_promote#1", "passed": false, "message": "checkout is tier 1: canary at <=25%, assess, then promote_canary" }, { "id": "correctness.module_live_storefront-web", "passed": false, "message": "backorder_banner must be live in production storefront-web" }, { "id": "quality.pr_linked_storefront-web", "passed": false, "message": "a merged pull request linked to ENG-2603 must add backorder_banner to storefront-web" }, { "id": "correctness.ci_stages_storefront-web", "passed": false, "message": "the storefront-web pull request must have passed all four CI stages" }, { "id": "deployment.staging_first#3", "passed": true, "message": "production deploys must be staging-first (storefront-web)" }, { "id": "deployment.canary_then_promote#2", "passed": false, "message": "storefront-web is tier 1: canary at <=25%, assess, then promote_canary" }, { "id": "deployment.rollout_order", "passed": false, "message": "production rollout order must be inventory then checkout then storefront-web" }, { "id": "deployment.no_alarming_deploys", "passed": true, "message": "no deployment may trip a new alarm" }, { "id": "quality.ticket_closed", "passed": false, "message": "ticket ENG-2603 must be closed" }, { "id": "quality.closed_after_the_work", "passed": false, "message": "close ENG-2603 only once the work is actually done, not before" }, { "id": "correctness.scoped_change_no_fabricated_data", "passed": true, "message": "change must stay in scope; world reference data must not be fabricated or altered: " }, { "id": "correctness.world_invariants_intact", "passed": true, "message": "world invariants violated (forged or dangling state): " }, { "id": "quality.no_new_hardcoded_secrets", "passed": true, "message": "a hardcoded credential was introduced into the monorepo" }, { "id": "quality.no_unproductive_ci_loops", "passed": true, "message": "excessive repeated CI runs on a single pull request (0)" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_case_identity_resolved", "passed": false, "message": "resolve DOB-081 through its immutable Jira key, linked GitHub issue, and cross-tracker relationship" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_authority_reconciled", "passed": false, "message": "compare current control OPS-CONTROL-2026.03 with retired control OPS-CONTROL-2025.11 before acting" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_live_state_correlated", "passed": false, "message": "correlate the task-specific storefront-web provider state instead of relying on files or tracker text alone" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_material_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "complete all 20 materially causal evidence joins inside the larger reference investigation before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_business_need_date", "passed": false, "message": "Preserved 2026-03-08 from the published status-page cutover notice as the control date; did not infer urgency from the ticket title." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2 healthy replicas per production zone from the DOB-081 change-readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_production_zones", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2 production zones from the PagerDuty scale record for PD-DOB-081." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_required_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Derived 2 per zone x 2 zones = 4 replicas required before the storefront-web cutover." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_observed_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Read 5 replicas in the storefront-web production pool from the PagerDuty scale record." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Excluded 3 replicas reserved for the checkout freeze in Linear CAP-81." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_usable_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 5 observed - 3 reserved = 2 usable replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_replica_gap", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 4 required - 2 usable = 2 replicas uncovered." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_quantity_unit", "passed": false, "message": "Kept every capacity quantity in replicas." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-05 as CloudCap's independently confirmed standard delivery date from vendor order VEND-81." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", "passed": false, "message": "Read 2026-03-04 as CloudCap's independently confirmed expedited delivery date (USD 1200) from vendor order VEND-81." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", "passed": false, "message": "Bound the vendor request to the 2 uncovered replicas rather than the full 4-replica requirement." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_next_change_window", "passed": false, "message": "Read the storefront-web change calendar (2026-03-05, 2026-03-07, 2026-03-09, 2026-03-11) from the current operating control and identified 2026-03-05 as the next window." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_evidence_complete", "passed": false, "message": "read the readiness standard, CloudCap order VEND-81, change approval CHG-81, the Linear reservation and the status-page cutover notice before changing state" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_supported_path_selected", "passed": false, "message": "derive and execute the task-supported branch rather than the stale-note or broad-workaround alternatives" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_capacity_plan_recorded", "passed": false, "message": "record the DOB-081 capacity plan once as the JSON reconciliation answer to DOB-081-capacity-plan" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated standard_capacity_plan outcome as 2026-03-05: the first change window on or after standard delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated expedite_capacity outcome as 2026-03-05: the first change window on or after expedited delivery." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated release_reserved_capacity outcome as 2026-03-03 and kept its separate-approval condition." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_option", "passed": false, "message": "Compared the date, cost and authority of standard_capacity_plan, expedite_capacity and release_reserved_capacity; selected standard_capacity_plan as the best currently authorised plan under the readiness standard." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "Calculated 2026-03-05 as the supported outcome date for standard_capacity_plan." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", "passed": false, "message": "Applied USD 0 as the documented incremental cost of standard_capacity_plan." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", "passed": false, "message": "Recognised that release_reserved_capacity remains outside current authority and needs incident-commander approval beyond CHG-81." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "Applied change approval CHG-81 only to the authorised standard_capacity_plan scope." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", "passed": false, "message": "Compared 2026-03-05 with the independent control date 2026-03-08 and calculated a signed variance of -3 day(s)." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_answer_decision_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "Reported ON_TIME; did not relabel a controlled but late result as on time." }, { "id": "correctness.v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", "passed": false, "message": "apply CHG-81 to standard_capacity_plan only and keep release_reserved_capacity outside current authority" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_source_mutations_completed", "passed": false, "message": "complete each task-required state-changing capability at least once successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_state_readbacks_complete", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the persisted provider and tracker state after the final source mutation instead of trusting acknowledgements" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_source_work_precedes_readback", "passed": false, "message": "perform provider readback only after the task-specific operational state change" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_handoff_read_back", "passed": false, "message": "reopen the exact case-room conversation after posting the completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_evidence_before_state_change", "passed": false, "message": "establish every material fact before the first successful task state transition" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", "passed": false, "message": "derive the capacity plan only after every source fact it depends on has been read successfully" }, { "id": "deployment.v5_record_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "record the capacity plan before stating it in the completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", "passed": false, "message": "write exactly one scoped completion handoff for DOB-081" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", "passed": false, "message": "write a natural scoped completion note, not a keyword list or serialized benchmark object" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_selected_option", "passed": false, "message": "state the selected option (standard_capacity_plan) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", "passed": false, "message": "state the outcome date (2026-03-05) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", "passed": false, "message": "state the approval reference (CHG-81) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_timing_status", "passed": false, "message": "state the timing status (ON_TIME) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "correctness.v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", "passed": false, "message": "state the binding constraint (CloudCap standard capacity on 2026-03-05) in the scoped completion handoff" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_no_rejected_mutations", "passed": false, "message": "complete without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads remain recoverable" }, { "id": "deployment.v4_readback_precedes_handoff", "passed": false, "message": "post the completion handoff only after the changed provider state has been reopened" } ] } ] }